HomeMy WebLinkAboutWhispering Pines Resort_12000990372000_Conditional Use Permits_11-20-2002n" ^ 0" *3 (j0>^
916351
OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER
OTTER TAIL MINNESOTA
I hereby certify that
this instrument #916951
was fiied/recorded in this office
for record on the 5 day of----------0^5;____2002 at (’./T^m^n^
'' RecorderWendy L. Metcaif, CouriW Rep
^ ^weii certificate
by:
1j:D-
THE ABOVE SPACE iS RESERVED FOR THE COUNTY RECORDER
APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL
121 W JUNIUS SUITE 130, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537
(218)739-2271
“‘COMPLETE THiS APPLiCATION iN BLACK INK***
/5'oApplication Fee.
Receipt Number
Accepted By / Date (I~ll0 ^
de/L6tAj
DAYTIME PHONEPROPERTY OWNER
ADDRESS /W£. A/■ Pl<^oUTM ^ h/jtV ^‘5'‘4'4L
'3^6' 3 6-DSio'-IZo LAKE CLASSLAKE NUMBER LAKE NAME
Co^L^iSSSECTIONTOWNSHIP /37
PARCEL NUMBER ^3llDC>0 ~ OS'V^OOO
RANGE TOWNSHIP NAME
(U>. ^E-911 ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
yO?5r - Lol" /3
CONDITIONAL USE PROJECT REQUESTED (Please circle the appropriate request)
(1) Topographical Alteration (2) Commercial Use ^ Cluster Development (4) Extractive Use (5) Industrial Use
(6) Forest Land Conversion (7) Miscellaneous
EXPLAIN YOUR REQUEST
ATTf^cHCb
I UNDERSTAND THAT APPROVAL OF THIS REQUEST APPLIES ONLY TO THE USE OF THE LAND.
I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED, IT IS MY RESPONSIBILITY TO
CONTACT LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT REGARDING THIS MATTER.
SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER DATE
APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT THE HEARING(Applicant Will Receive Notification As To The Date/Time Of Hearing)
BK-0600-006 305.909 • Vicior Lundeen Co.. Printers • Fergus Falls. MN • 1-800-346-4870
Date Of Planning commission Hearing
Planning Commission Motion
November 20, 2002:
Motion: A motion by Lachowitzer, second by Maske to approve as presented, provided
that any further requests require the removal of cabin 10. Reason for approval being
that there will not be any increase in the number of dwelling units.
Chairman/Otter Tail County Planning Commission
County Board Action
\/^ Approved As Recommended
Denied As Recommended
Other
UjsLi^ J
Date of Final Action
0 2-
Chairman/Otter Tail County Board of Commissioners
ICONDITIONAL USE PERMIT# ^
L « R Official / Date
Permjt^s) reniiired from I and ft RpsniJrne~M*naaement
Yes (Contact Land & Resource Management No
Copy of Application Mailed to Applicant And MN DNR
L & R Official / Date
✓
OTTER TAIL COUNTY
Conditional Use Permit # 655k
Owner’s Narne rlM.j
Kd^ cbrttM
Location: Lakel'^*‘RO Sec. 5\ Twp. ftT Range J7 jwp. NarneO** titj
U-oo0'<j^-03li-(M >4L»^/»n
l*-~000 •
^ e^Lx* t«f <yi (itJuA Afck')
Use ^MiCiocW^
Vg^ricutce
(tdeu^s cv\
4^
fiyiATMCUi—^
Lana and Resource Management Official
ttjl/etIssued:Expires:
1. Earthmoving shall be done between
2. Entire area shall be stabilized within 10 days of the completion of any earthmoving.
3. Owner is legaiiy responsible for all surface water drainage that may occur.
4. No fiil shail enter or be taken from the beds of a public water without a valid permit from the State of Minnesota Department of
Naturai Resources.
5. If the terms of this permit are violated the entire permit may be revoked and the owner may be subject to legal prosecution.
6. This card shall be placed in a conspicuous place not more than 4 feet above grade on the premises on which work is to be done,
and shall be maintained there until completion of such work.
7. NOTIFY DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, TELEPHONE (218) 739-2271, WHEN AUTHORIZED
WORK HAS BEEN COMPLETED.
&
BK-1099-046
298,111 • Vicior Lundeeri Co., Printers • Fergus Falls, MN • ^600-^46-4e70
OTC Board of Commissioners’ Minutes
November 26, 2002
Page 3
Approval of Agenda
Motion by Froemming, second by Lee, and unanimously carried to approve the County Board
agenda of November 26, 2002, with the following addition:
Discussion - Correspondence Regarding PGOLID
Approval of Minutes
Motion by Nelson, second by Block, and unanimously carried to approve the County Board
minutes of November 19, 2002, as presented.
Approval to Pay Bills
Motion by Lee, second by Froemming, and unanimously carried to approve payment of the
County Board bills per Attachment A of these minutes, which includes the following lodging
payment:
Correction Officers, Mike Jensen & Bob HjelmenAmericinn
Planning Commission Recommendations
Land & Resource Director, Bill Kalar, and Planning Commission member, Leona Zimmerman,
were present during consideration of Planning Commission recommendations.
Conditional Use Permit - “Whispering Pines Resort’YRobert Corbin:
Motion by Nelson, second by Lee, and unanimously carried to approve a Conditional Use
Permit to replace a cabin and remodel other cabins at the resort with conditions as
recommended by the Planning Commission. The property is described as Lewis Ward
Martin’s Perfect Beach Lot 8 - Lot 13, Section 31 of Corliss Township, Big Pine Lake
(56-130).
Conditional Use Permit - Dan & Steph Baker:
Motion by Nelson, second by Block, and unanimously carried to deny a Conditional Use
Permit for Dan & Steph Baker for the reasons stated by the Planning Commission. The
property is described as Lot 9, Block 1 of Rose Acres, Section 17 of Hobart Township, Rose
Lake (56-360).
Conditional Use Permit - Galen L. & Laura A. Youngsma:
Land & Resource Director, Bill Kalar, reported that the Planning Commission recommended
denial of a CUP for Galen & Laura Youngsma. Laura Youngsma requested that this CUP
request be tabled until the May, 2002, Planning Commission meeting to allow time to address
the water run-off and soil condition issues. Lengthy discussion took place regarding the
length of time to be tabled, notification of neighbors, the 60-day rule, and whether or not this
would be considered a different plan. Mr. Kalar stated that there are some positives in the
current plan as the existing cabin and a portion of the driveway to be removed are currently
very close to the lake. Mr. Kalar did share concerns with surface water run-off issues.
Motion by Froemming, second by Nelson, to table the Conditional Use Permit request of
Galen and Laura Youngsma until May, 2003, subject to the applicant waiving the 60-day rule.
Chair Mosher called for a roll call vote:
Froemming YeaCommission District 4
Nelson NayCommission District 1
Block YeaCommission District 5
Lee NayCommission District 2
Mosher NayCommission District 3
OTTER TAIL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
218-739-2271 Ext. 225Otter Tail County Courthouse, Fergus Falls, MN 56537
November 20, 2002
Meeting of the Otter Tail County Planning Commission was held on November 20, 2002
at 6:30 P.M. in the Commissioner's Room, Courthouse, Fergus Falls, Minnesota.
Roll Call:
Members Present; Linda Bergerud, Rod Boyer, Frank Lachowitzer, Joe Maske, Bert
Olson, Robert Schwartz, Richard Sha, and Leona Zimmerman.
Members Absent: Les Estes and David Trites.
Barb Hanson represented the County Attorney's Office and Bill Kalar represented the
Land & Resource Management Office.
“Whispering Pines Resort” / Robert Corbin - Approved With A Condition:
A Conditional Use Permit Application request to replace cabin 5 (24’ x 32’ with a 12/12
roof pitch), change the roof pitch to cabin 9 (12/12), drop plans (CUP 5984)) to alter cabin
7, tear down cabin 12, relocate cabin 6 to the second row of cabins and construct a
replacement cabin (24’ x 40’ with a 12/12 roof pitch) in the old cabin of cabin 6. The
changes result in no increase in dwelling units. The property is described as Lewis Ward
Martin’s Perfect Beach Lot 8 - Lot 13, Section 31 of Corliss Township: Big Pine (56-130),
GD.
Robert Corbin represented the Application.
Motion: A motion by Lachowitzer, second by Maske to approve as presented, provided
that any further requests require the removal of cabin 10. Reason for approval being that
there will not be any increase in the number of dwelling units. Voting: All Members in
favor.
Dan & Steph Baker - Denied:
A Conditional Use Permit Application stating the following request. Move front wetland
and connect it to the rear wetland. Place 1300 cubic yards of fill for building site and road
construction. (This is an After-The-Fact request.) The property is described as Lot 9,
Block 1 of Rose Acres, Section 17 of Hobart Township; Rose Lake (56-360), RD.
Dan Baker represented the Application.
Lyle Krieg indicated that he has lowland on his lot also and stated that he thought the
wetland was supposedly manmade. John Bunnell questioned the possibility of a
negative effect resulting from filling as requested, he expressed concerns regarding the
unknown impact on neighboring lots.
Motion: A motion by Sha, second by Lachowitzer to deny; reasons as follows; 1. An
adequate building site is available onsite where disturbance of the wetland could be
avoided. 2. There is potential negative impact on the neighboring lot. Voting: All
Members in favor.
OTTER TAIL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
APPLICANT:Robert Corbin
Whispering Pines Resort
13820 58'^Ave N
Plymouth MN 55446
HEARING DATE/LOCATION: November 20, 2002 at 6:30 P.M. **
Commissioner's Room,
Otter Tail County Courthouse
(Use the West Law Enforcement Entrance)
121 W Junius
Fergus Falls, MN 56537
PROJECT DESCRIPTION (AS STATED ON THE APPLICATION): A Conditional Use
Permit Application to (see other side of Notice for request)
LAKE NAME/NUMBER/CLASS: Big Pine (56-130), GD
E-911 ADDRESS: 46362 Co Hwy 8
LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lewis Ward Martin’s Perfect Beach Lot 8 - Lot 13, Section 31 of
Corliss Township
** Weather Conditions may change the Hearing date and time. If bad weather occurs, please listen to the local Fergus
Falls Radio Stations or contact the Land & Resource Management Office, by 4:30 p.m., for possible rescheduling of the
Hearing.
The above Applicant has made Application to the Otter Tail County Planning Commission
for a Conditional Use Permit as per the requirements of the Shoreland Management
Ordinance of Otter Tail County. Details of the Application are available for viewing at the
Land & Resource Management Office, 121 W Junius Suite 130, Fergus Falls, MN 56537.
Any comments regarding this request may be expressed at the Hearing or forwarded to the
Land & Resource Management Office.
INDIVIDUALS REQUIRING SPECIAL ACCOMMODATIONS SHOULD CONTACT THE
LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT OFFICE PRIOR TO THE HEARING.
November 6, 2002Bert Olson
Chairman Planning Commission Mailing Date
f0.CK^1+ -(or Cond
cLa(-€(\ (O-n-OZ-
On September 11th, 2002, a request for a Conditional Use Permit change allowing us to increase the size
of cabins 5,7, and 9 of Whispering Pines Resort on Big Pine Lake was presented and approved. The
County Commissioners also subsequently followed the recommendation of the Planning Commission and
approved this original request. The approved change was to add a 20’ by 16’ addition to cabin 9, a 20’ by
12’ addition to cabin 7, and a 24’ by 6’ addition to cabin 5.
We have worked with a local contractor to plan the construction. In his opinion, the cabin 5 foundation
should be rebuilt before the addition to that cabin is constructed. In order to rectify the issue, 1 am seeking
permission to tear the cabin down, rebuild the foundation, and rebuild the cabin to the 24’x32’ size
approved in the recent conditional use permit process. Tearing the cabin down, in my opinion, is a more
economical and practical alternative than trying to lift the structure and redo the foundation.
We also did some work with the contractor on the cabin design. We would like to change the roof of
cabins 5 and 9. The existing cabins have a 3/12 pitch roof We would like to change the roofs to a 12/12
pitch. The existing cabins are both 2-bedroom structures. After the cabin changes are complete, cabins 5
and 9 would be a 1-bedroom and 2-bedroom, respectively, each with a sleeping loft at the back of the
cabin, with the front of the cabin being an open design, floor to roof The revised design will allow us to
improve the living room, kitchen, and bathroom size and the overall aesthetics of the cabin.
We are temporarily dropping our plans to alter cabin 7 and have developed an alternative plan after
working with the contractor. We would like to tear down cabin 12, which is located within the 50’-foot
setback from the North edge of the property. This change is associated with moving cabin 6 to the second
of cabins, and constructing another 24’x^fe’ cabin in that original location. This cabin would also
ast'
row
have a 12/12 roof pitch. Cabin 6 would be placed on the south side of cabin 11, in conformance with the
50’ setback.
The roof changes to cabin 9 and the demolition of cabin 12 are also being presented to the Board of
Adjustment, since they are within the 50’ setback on the North side of the property. Ai-i~ t
Z) uj ,-T^ rzyc /k.c/’r-er-v./V/
f«.c W n+ ^
(O' n-o 2-
f V - ../
;i:
9
On September 11th, 2002, a request for a Conditional Use Permit change allowing us to increase the size
of cabins 5,7, and.9 of Whispering Pines Resort on Big Pine Lake was presented and approved. The
County Commfissioners also subsequently followed the recommendation ofthe Planning Commission and
approved this original request. The approved change was to add a 20’ by 16’ addition to cabin 9, a 20’ by
12’ addition to cabin 7, and a 24’ by 6’ addition to cabin 5.
We have worked with a local contractor to plan the construction. In his opinion, the cabin 5 foundation
should be rebuilt before tbe addition to that cabin is constructed. In order to rectify the issue, I am seeking
permission to tear the cabin down, rebuild the foundation, and rebuild the cabin to the 24’x32’ size
approved in the recent conditional use permit process. Tearing the cabin down, in my opinion, is a more
economical and practical alternative than trying to lift the structure and redo the foundation.
We also did some work with the contractor on the cabin design. We would like to change the roof of
cabins 5 and 9. The existing cabins have a 3/12 pitch roof We would like to change the roofe to a 12/12
pitch. The existing cabins are both 2-bedroom structures. After the cabin changes are complete, cabins 5
and 9 would be a 1-bedroom and 2-bedroom, respectively, each with a sleeping loft at the back of the
cabin, with the fi'ont of the cabin being an open design, floor to roof The revised design will allow us to
improve the living room, kitchen, and bathroom size and the overall aesthetics of the cabin.
• r-
We are temporarily dropping our plans to alter cabin 7 and have developed an alternative plan after
working with the contractor. We would like to tear down cabin 12, which is located within the 50-’-foot
-setback fi-om the North edge of the property. This change is associated vinth moving cabin 6 to the second row of cabins, and constructing another 24’xjl^’ cabin in that original location. This cabin would also
have a 12/12 roof pitch. Cabin 6 would be placed on the south side of cabin ,11, in conformance with the
50’setback.
a*/'
The roof changes to cabin 9 and the demolition of cabin 12 are also being presented to the Board of
Adjustment, since they are within the 50’ setback on the North side of the property. A t-t-
^CSuLT A/i) /-N/
•<
;■
I
J ifI<2)I
;I-V^A*-
!I SCALE I" = 100'i ;A^y-^ .w y I
A. ^ V X A
i :
;I u(i jVA ^‘vvT,I f I^cjiki. Iz^ aLjj
‘ :^l£i Ie«j 4,Lj tlczA. JL iUi £u2,Ji^Lj.
(fVJv^,I
r.vAiui I
^1
t
:0\
vO r',•■ -■\
; .1 r-
i:+*k#>«.' ,;; .-,4-’«a.r.;. •
■ f
!
i9ql
f I
t\^ \■*;■
=4fc» i,'is..j ■
■- 'i .i
, /o, //,
^CACH, OTTER
'■» ^^ !3 of LEWIS WARD
tail GOJNTY, MINNESOTA
'■5»F S-i MARm'S
!f’ ' i
-
y.n :y.-f v ;: -':< ; ;■;■■ ;;-:Svx „;■:'- X , X XrWXSnxSt'X < X X x.-’x ;: - X :: X-CERTIFICATE OP SURVEY
ROBERT B. 05LUND & fiSSOCIATES
OMK ENGINEERING, INC.
:•:
•■; •
i .
i KEGISTEREI) LAND SURVEYORS
OTTER TAi;. COUNTY SURVEYOR
ICj BOUXU CASCADE
328 WEST 5TH ST.
DEK MT'l)IM(rPsW>ERVTSWN'A?JD TO\t^i Vm A^'mr? v "PRKPARFO ME OR UN-
S OF TOE ^ATC^?i«N.\ESOTl Bt«fSTERED L.VM> SUR\ EYOIl
X — CONSULTING CIVIL ENGINEERS
— KANDIYOHI COU.N'TY SURVEYOR
FERGUS FALLS. MINN. 56S37
WILLMAR. MINN 56201 PH. 736.4272
PH. 235-4012
I?m:I •.*i I
r’
!I(
Cf^L.C.t^L.ATiOrJ
C<2o):B.P,^,l/J H)SP£Pli^ <5 Pjt/es P.CSc(L\
r.
/l-l^o«*
13 ^ fp3<^4» "7 j {AtJ >T
vftatA ; ^jV rr^
•\
liT P<f<^
^5; rr^I2<^l‘ X (^00
U>0 T
3 u/^ir^
i/zv'/t “ 3 I 3 UtJiT^
U *V I T~^X /- 5* -
[5;____!l
/
- Q.,\l ^ i^hfirs
3 jJ/P/TA
3c2i» ^ 5^7
-^7^ T
5 y /. S' -
li 3<?s> /
^7,<5vj - ( f‘i'/< IJ‘' - 'S’l^S'g,? fr^
-7 ju^iT -
3 t^/v;T4 X ^
r^i ^/
I
3
V UhJ\TS
(E)j
M rw TietL
/37'
/3,337 rr^
o. A ^
^ ^ - 13^^37 rr^
T ^4>jOOo It^tJiT “
0. 6>^ ^ / Uf^iT
I
3^5!>■
I
S' •/ 2f V ^ /43 i/*'/r377!7T)i.
(g^
V^".,.. :SiU ..
I^rr \i-
I
I/V 1i i;
a“-
i SCALE l" = 100 I\I!
* UaicaLs, Le**i AjLuj ^uJ.
^ >ASffiri^t£Icoj 4'L/j
^ i^l€* lAiSe£t£A Uy£^fd ”:
*
f
\
j!•/•;
9.10. „,,^and J3 of LEWIS WARD
tail county, MINNESOTA martin'sRFECTlEACH, OTTERf.
\ ■ .
- ‘ ■!XA Vx'f -::-• V A X:n;>:5£;x*-x ^'x ;■:- :•: r :’X :: - X' •••• 'CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY
ROBERT B. OSLUND & fiSSOCIATES
OMK ENGINEERING, INC.
!K'EGISTEREI) LAND SURVEYORS
OTTER TAIL COUNTY SURVEYOR
iC5 eOUXll CASCADE
3M WEST STH ST.
:•;— CONSULTING CIVIL ENGINEERS.> .■
— KANDIYOHI COU.N-TY SURVEYOR
FERQUS FALLS. MINN. S6537
WILLMAR, MINN 56201
X
PH. 73!j-42;2
OF TIIE ^ATE OF ^N.\ eIotI ' KKifSTKIlED LAND .SUnVEYOU
#
I
1 i
Whispering Pines Resort
Big Pine Lake
•642’Oo
v:Vy\RV\□□ □ i1&2\\[\Lodge \\Bait\\Women Men '\\\\House \Shop3\\\\
\\\V\\4 ••••\I \\\D D D D D D \\\\
\\\\\.\□\Fish
Cleaning
\\5 i 6'x24’
5 I Addition \448’■\
RV \122-"1 \X \\\
D D D I\\6 \\12'x20‘
Addition
\\\\\153’326’\\RV7\114-’\■adwell\\
\\\8 RV16'x20’ [—
Addition ^ ^\\I 90’\
\\I I I 1\\\\9\12118’-•>\\A *\\10 \32’i 1
>864.5’
Total Area = 24,624 Sq Ft ^\r=iT
V
Whispering Pines Resort
Big Pine Lake
M2’
I □1&2
LodgeBait\Women Men
House\
\3 •Tear down and
rebuild 24’x32'
cabin with 12/12
pitch roof
\\\\\\\
1 4 •Tear down cabin 12 which is inside
of 50" zone
•Move cabin 6 to the back row to new
location outside of 50' zone
•Rebuild 24'x^' cabin with 12/12
pitch roof
\
\D D D D DD
rv
D D DD
\\\
□\Fish
Cleaningi\
5\
122’V
\]\\\6\RV \\\\I 153’326’ \\•Change roof
from 3/12 pitch to
12/12 pitch
\Dwell7\/114’6•>i\\RV \\\\\1 \8\\90’..\..\11\\\\..........\
M9 \\\118’-\\\\\\10 \32’\t
8M.5’>
Total Area = 24,624 Sq Ft 1”=72’