The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSwan Lake Resort_13000290193003_Conditional Use Permits_10-05-1988/OS-IM- APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT - Shoreland Management Ordinance Otter Tail County Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 9'7&3UW.ooApplication Fee $Rec. No.19Date: S<p ^^^Sec. 3*^ Twp. V31- Range Twp. Name Legal description of land: Lake No. H£>LavcC.Lake ClassLake Name S '4SfalFire No.Legal Description:\‘=(.S(^sr c>^ */M S 33' ov e 9,ec Gv: •S'S fG 3S'1 \3 - OoQ - oo3Parcel Number: Project Description: L>J ^SK To ^ (o CPlrrsf\t^Cr ^ v-tK (i'\ To fsOO ^ I-r«-S LOivvt:*^- ^L-«.orRNC , la-?. u-5lSw^o Aoo To (2.-€S« f-)T LO q-T e ft. s, C Lec\ iiL N c Sv‘T€.S, . V-0«- '» p' '^0(V>f StPiT'v.ot>^ *2 \ t^G V GT V fOG TAn^NC, In order to properly evaluate the situation, piease provide as much supplementary information as possible, such as: maps, plans, information about surrounding property, etc. APP\-\C\AH'\ SHALL BE PRESENT AT THE SCHEDULED HEARING. RT- G 4^^^ Home Ph. ~1 3 M- Lg>*>-Le> gj/j p/j "73* ^ Address: ^CLa>\V<(v~Owner: C.,A-.Applicant Signature: 7'onTime:Date of hearing: Applicant changed ftU acquest to o6k ioK 10 additional &ita, and Conditional Requirements: lo dclctc the fiequQAt {^oK. ^eiveA hook-up-6 and a dump station. Application WOA tabled until the Vec. Mtg. {oa the next -scheduled mtg. theneaiteK] to allow M/l. Tfiahm to apply {^ofi a variance in.om the B.A. MlHUt Pen. letten. received, the P.C. con6iden.ed this, application to be wlthrtuxiwn. [See iile ion. letten] This applig^ion is hereby recommended for approval by the Otter Tail County Planning Advisory Commission.tvAV'- pk«tst v€J(tW •felvft.. ^10.00 Chairman 19Approved by the Board of County Commissioners of Otter Tail County this day of ap>uo».W3n’5 b«'Cn%plcial Ose Perfiit issued in accordance with compliance with existing Conditional Requirements and Special Regulations and yuifKd^ftu/llr-Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources notified this NDITIONAL <e.Chairman , 19day of IT NO. MKL-0871-01-01 Malcolm K. Lee, Shoreland Administrator Otter Tail County, Minnesota 220707 @ FCRQua falls. MINN.VICTOR LUN0EE1 PRIN' Otter Tail County Planning Commission County Court House Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 December 9, 1988 Dennis Frahm R#6 Box 246 Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Dear Mr. Frahm: This is to inform you that at the December 9, 1988 meeting of the Otter Tail County Planning Commission it was decided to consider your conditional use application as being withdrawn (per the letter that was received). Sincerely, Marsha Bowman Acting Secretary OTCPC Planning Commission December 7, 1988 Page 2 Per letter received, the Planning Commission considers the conditional use application of Dennis Frahm, Swan Lake, 56-781, RD, Swan Lake Resort, Section 29 of Dane Prairie Township as withdrawn (see attached). Withdrawn: A motion by Petterson, second by Femling to approve the conditional use application of Kathleen McNabb, Lake Lida, 56- 747, GD, Lot 3, Block 7, Crystal Lida Beaches (6.4 Acres), Section 11, Lida Township allowing a total of 9 units; allowing numbers 1 through 6, 12, 13 & 14 these sites are to be located as indicated on Exhibit A (signed by Kathleen McNabb, dated December 7, 1988). This tract (E 6.4 Ac of Lot 3, Block 7) is being considered as a separate project and is not being considered as part of the existing Resort. Charles Krekelberg, Attorney, accompanied the applicant; Rod Ebersviller, Carla Perkins and Scott Johnson expressed concerns and objections to this application. Approved; Voting: All members in favor, except Stringer abstained. A motion by Lachowitzer, second by Lee to approve the conditional use application of Andrew A. Klinnert, Rush Lake, 56-141, GD, Pt. of G.L. 3, Section 23, Rush Lake Township provided he stays 6" below the ice ridge and must leave as many trees as possible, the slope must run away from the lake. Approved: Voting: All members in favor. A motion by Petterson, second by Schwartz to extend the deadline for Charles Kochmann, et al. Otter Tail Lake, 56-242, on Conditional Use Permit //3622 to May 15, 1989. Extended: Voting: All members in favor. A motion by Stringer, second by Hatling to nominate Cecil Femling as Chairman, motion by Lachowitzer to cease nominations passed. Election: Voting: All members in favor. A motion by Femling, second by Lachowitzer to nominate Noble Hatling as Secretary passed. Voting: All members in favor. RECEIVEL ^’0'/ 3 0 J988 lAND & RESOURCE November 29, 1988 Otter Tail County Planning Commission County Court House Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Dear Sirs: Please delete us from the agenda for the December 7, 1988 meeting of the Planning Commision. We have taken the information received at the October 5 meeting into consideration and will not be applying for a variance from the Board of Adjustment at this time. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Dennis L. Frahm Swan Lake Resort Rt. 6 Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Dept, of Land and Resource Managmentcc: Department of LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL Phone 218-739-2271 Court House Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 MALCOLM K. LEE, Administrator November 30, 1988 Dennis and Stephanie Frahm Swan Lake Resort R#6 Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Resort Expansion, Swan Lake (56-781).RE: Dear Mr. & Mrs. Frahm: In response to your letter dated November 28, 1988, I personally became involved with your proposed resort expansion on August 23, 1988. time, you filed your completed Conditional Use Permit Application form and sketch with our office. At this As you may recall, I mentioned that I would review your proposal in order to determine whether or not a variance from the provisions of the Shoreland Management Ordinance of Otter Tail County would also be required in order for your expansion to occur. The Ordinance (copy enclosed), as you will see, requires 26,666 square feet of land area and 50 feet of water frontage per dwelling unit. It is my understanding that your property consists of 19.56 acres of land and 790 feet of lake frontage, therefore the following calculations were made. 1. Land Area 19.56 acres X 43,560 sq ft = 852,034 sq ft acre 852,034 sq ft X dwellinR unit = 32 dwelling units (total) 26,666 sq ft 2. Lake Frontage 790 ft X dwelling unit = 16 dwelling units (total) 50 ft SHORELAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE - DIVISION OF EMERGENCY SERVICE - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE SOLID WASTE ORDINANCE SEWAGE SYSTEM CLEANERS ORDINANCE - RECORDER, OTTER TAIL COUNTY PLANNING ADVISORY COMMISSION RIGHT-OF-WAY SETBACK ORDINANCE FUEL AND ENERGY COORDINATION . >Novmber 30, 1988 Page 2 From these calculations, it becomes apparent that your property would be allowed 16 dwelling units (total) without a variance based on the most limiting factor, water frontage. In practice, however the Planning Commission has often averaged these numbers which if done in this case would result in 24 dwelling units (total) being recommended for approval on this property. Your Conditional Use Permit application indicated that currently onsite were 35 dwelling units (1 residence, 30 campsites and 4 rental cabins). This means that the number of dwelling units currently on your property without your proposed 10 dwelling unit expansion exceeds the maximum allowable dwelling unit density as per the provisions of the Ordinance Since this was the case, on August 24, 1988, I informed you (telephone conversation) of my calculations as well as the need for a variance from the Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment. This was done so that you would not be surprised at the Planning Commission Meeting and so you would have sufficient time to apply for a variance during the same time your Conditional Use Permit Application was being considered. Your letter also indicates that I informed you that 45 dwelling units could be placed on your property. At this time, I have no recollection of indicating to you that 45 dwelling units could be on your property. As previously indicated I became involved in this matter upon receipt of your Conditional Use Application in which you requested 45 dwelling units. Pr ease note, I make it a point not to comment on what the Planning Commission or Board of Adjustment may or may not approve. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact our office. Sincerely, Bill Kalar Aset. Administrator mgb ^3 H 7fe' ^ S’o'= 2)G^\Jie>- ( ^ (5>i'-*o. J /Ac^'W 0 34 Fiy-M 3 I ^ ^ /y^aaJ ■<^■ ®/'vtXm<\,*v*-<, ^^i^e,RssouRcr L November 28, 1988 Bill Kalar Dept, of Land & Resource Management County of Otter Tail Court House Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Dear Mr. Kalar: As you.can see by the enclosed copy of the letter to the Planning Commission we will not be applying for a variance from the Board of Adjustments at this time. Many things contributed to this decision including the high cost of the additions. One thing we would like to clarify though is the number of dwelling sites we can have on'our property. When we initially talked to you before the October 5th Planning Commission Meeting you indicated we could have 45 dwelling sites but at the meeting you indicated we were entitled to only about 30. That was a surprise to us. Would you please verify which is to correct total and perhaps indicate to us why the big discrepancy? We would appreciate it for any further plans we may have to improve our resort. We thank you for all of the other information we received from you too. Sincerely, Stephanie and Dennis Frahm Swan Lake Resort Rt. 6 Fergus Falls, MN 56537 736-4626 iZ' 1-nPLAmWG C0MM75S70W MOTIONS APPLICANT: »i MOTION BV: SECONV By: UJTNESSES: OiffUUCcLtf^ jo ABSTAINNOYES ACKLEY FEMLING HATLJNG LACHOWJTZEP LEE OLSON PETTERSON SCHWARTZ STRINGER TRUES ALL MEMBERS IN FAVOR Otter Tail County Planning Commission County Court House Fergus Falls, Mifinesota 56537 October 7, 1988 Dennis Frahm R#6 Box 426 Fergus Falls, MN 56537 Dear Mr. Frahm: This is to inform you that at the October 5, 1988 meeting of the Otter Tail County Planning Commission a motion was passed to table your conditional use application until the December 1988 meeting (or the first meeting thereafter), allowing the applicant the opportunity to apply for a variance from the Board of Adjustment. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact the Land & Resource Management Office. Sincerely, Marsha Bowman Acting Secretary OTCPC Otter Tail County Planning Commission County Court House Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 October 5, 1988 Meeting of the Otter Tail County Planning Conuniaaion waa held on October 5, 1988 at 7:00 P.M. in the Commiaaionera Room. Court Houae* Fergua Falla. Minneaota 56537. Mike Ackley, Cecil Femling, Frank Lachowitzer. Bert Olson. Victor Petterson Jr Tritea. Kalar Land & Reaource Management were alao present. Members Present; Robert Schwartz. Tom Stringer, David Wally Senyk, County Attorney's Office and Bill• • Noble Hatling and Reba Lee.Members Absent; A motion by Lachowitzer. second by Petterson to approve the minutes of the September 7, 1988 meeting as mailed. Approved Voting; All members in favor. A motion by Femling, second by Petterson to approve the conditional use application of Alfred E. Briggs and Bill Eggermont, Pelican Lake, 56-7 86, GD, on Pt. Sublot C of Lot 1. Section 3, Dunn Township as presented, which includes approval of operating a commercial business. Jay Carlson, attorney, accompanied the applicant. Approved; Voting; All members in favor. Conditional use applicant, Dennis Frahm. Swan Lake, 56-781. RD, Swan Lake Resort. Section 29, Dane Prairie Township revised his request to ask for 10 additional sites and delete the request for sewer hook-ups and a dump station. Revised: A motion by Stringer, second by Lachowitzer to table the conditional use application of Dennis Frahm. Swan Lake, 56- 781 until the December Meeting (or the next scheduled meeting thereafter) and to allow Mr. Frahm the opportunity to apply for a variance from the Board of Adjustment. Krawiecki, County Health Department spoke to the Commission. Tabled: Brian Voting; All members in favor. APPLICANT MoncM By PLANNING COMMISSION MOTIONS (}o nnc> p'a-hM - SiAM/v^ lM4-~ ^QT-j________________ SECONV BY WITNESSES Cyfvj vi-f^' (^GflU^y^ yU^ '(pi(iMl^ yjvj. ^^(UAM ViL.:cOo' uy(s<-^ P .cvp^ lluc^ 4 (Tu^ ^10.\ (//^,1 //K 0A^oO C>^(>-''tV' (K NO ABSTAINYES ! ACKLEY ' FEMLJNG HATLING LACHOWITZER LEE OLSON PETTERSON SCHWARTZ STRINGER TRUES ALL MEMBERS IN FAt/OR ./ SHORELAND MANAGEMENT OtTER TAIL COUNTY Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 NOTICE OF HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT HEARING TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN;Dennis Frahm Rt. 6 Box 426 Fergus Falls* MN 56537 has made application to the Otter Tail County Planning Commission for a Conditional Use Permit as per requirements of the Otter Tail County Shoreland Management Ordinance. The Otter Tail County 19_^October 5thPlanning Commission will assemble for this hearing on Time 7:00 P.M. Place Commissioner's Room. Court House Fergus Falls, Minnesota. This notice is to advise you that you may attend the above hearing and express your views on the Conditional Use requested. The property concerned in the application is legally described as: <Twp. Name rianp P'ra^r^pLake No.5h=Z&2— Sec. 7Q Twp. 137 Range 47 Fire No. S 4561ClassLake Name: Swan Lake RD 29, 132, 42 S'ly 650’ of NW%; SWJs Ex S 33' of E 231' Rec Bk 85 Pg 357________________________ 19.56 THE CONDITIONAL USE REQUESTED IS: We wish to add 6 camping sites with water, electric, & sewer.. We wish to add 4 camping sites with water & electric. We wish to add sewer hook-ups to 2 present water & electric sites. We wish to put in a dump station utilizing an existing septic tank. 1 Map can be viewed at the Land & Resource Office, Court House, Fergus Falls, Minnesota, during normal Court House hours. 1988flppl-pmhpr 1 6Dated. Otter Tail County Planning Commission Chm. MKL -0871-011 By:. 2219101®VICTOR WNOEEN A CO.. PRINTERS. FERGUS FALLS, yiNN. .t-’i :9?Xt:* m f ffU * ^ Itc^ s o 3 OC. ulO Ci I cm-Ti'S' <D ] JV «l* 4^^'-II■I C?y3a^£:^..S>9' * ■! ■ *ift i il Ai 1 liil fmmiSs i ^-4.E*ai* ■i? % •# 4^^" ' fc:- '^r i: f l» li it f-■fa-Ssjm»» il I iImiiff - *-,* - ". ?- f, ItM ~ Im ■I;:i ,, . _ ■»44. ¥■ mm-s^i ^ ^&':§iE. E t'a ■II's..if 4' IIfcs- «.f ■1 i6 eM-y.. --i- KaS:»:SC:«l:,siSiws'fE-fs ■ '■ ^■ yyBSusn m «-f- i'Al'. -StWM i #smi. -&<I ■te'■if-m i mt :3:',--"4'- f:' i'SSi «■ft.Vl ;K ' *1 mmmyt 4 *1 .kM DytcU -p3V'y7cuo Vw5 ' o-C VJt OLDp^oVtU lVv^^MS Qont^. Q^pJ>lKtt4(on, i\NA