HomeMy WebLinkAboutMallard Bay Resort_41000030019002_Conditional Use Permits_11-09-1971APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL USE PERMIT
Shoreland Management Ordinance
Otter Tail County
Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537 7-White — Office
Yellow — Applicant
Application Fee $ -00 Permit No.19 71Date----Nov ember 9
Two. 1 19 Range _3S.Twp. Name Ni daro.sLegal description of land: Lake No. Sf>-]01 Sec__3.
Part of Government Lot 8, Section 3, Township 132, Range 39.
Area is Southwest and adjacent to Mallard Bay Resort.
On Stuart Lake, a Recreational Development Lake.
■Sketch .supp 11 edSketch and supporting data submitted
PROPOSED USE OF LAND:
Construct and operate a fifty (50) stall camper-travel trailer facility
in conjunction with Mallard Bay Resort. Individual parking stall, water
and sewage service will not be available (Dependent sites). Included
in plan is a 24 x 48 foot comfort station building where water, shower
and rest room accomodations will be located. Approximately 8 acres of
land Included in camper-travel trailer area.
fill 71-h Sl-rppt- W.WRiihen F. Htiher________________AddressApplicant.
____________Pari haul t-j Minnp.«;n ta
Home Phone 612-3.34-7852
Applicant Signature
Bus. Phone 612-645-5633
,19_71 8;00 P.MDecember 1 Time.Date of Hearing
CONDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS:
This application is hereby recommended for approval by the Otter Tail County Planning Advisory Commission.
Chairman
day of..19Approved by the Board of County Commissioners of Otter Tail County this.
Chairman
Special Use Permit issued in accordance with compliance with existing Conditional Requirements and Special Regulations and
19.day of.Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources notified this
SPECIAL USE PERMIT NO.
Malcolm K. Lee, Shoreland Administrator
Otter Tall County. Minnesota
MKL-0871-010
159034-A ®vicre* LuUfcti • e« »antn*> rcaau* waa
0- ' ■ % J. ’- ' -
’■ \v- ■I y 7y!". I i t I ,j,' i Cm I ■ ! i I■J
(!,r.- =:
i'ioccr.'.b''r j,i','71
;:r. Ruben F. Huber
8^1 “ 7th St. H.W.
Faribnu'i-1, Minnesota 55c:i
Dear Mr. Huber:r
This confirrr.s action taker, by the Otter Tail County Piarr.inr,
.■ Advisory Ccnmission at their treeting on Decerriber 1, 1971 held
at 3:00 P.M, in the Cortr'.issicrar' s Chambers, Court House,
.Fergus Falls, Minnesota,, as follows:
1*
i Passed a motion by Billon, second by Beck to deny a Special
Use Permit to Ruben F. Huber, Faribault, Minnesota for the
.-construction, and operation of a.fifty (50) stall camperr
'-..travel.;, trailer facility .in coiijunc'tio.n with Mallard Cay Resort,
■'Stuart Lake, Mo. .56-191 as per your aoplicaticn dated November 9,
■U97.i;. '
-. ■■ •r i-
:■
^ •L-
?:• u. f C:; .■ ■■ '
- .iu .Si. y*'-" -st^ ■■>.
.p.
=3'.C:
■ - - ^ •
'V •r
Voting Yes:ALtstadt, Aho, Beck, Estes, Dillon, Fritz,
HalmstroQ, D. Nelson, H. Nelson^' Revering.•'i 't-'f.-
y. /•-
' Voting No:Hone• f-v*.
Motion Passed.
• '«<■
-V
Sincerely,'...-b .
Maiccim ;-l. i.e-e
Secre t.r
Otter Tail Cou;;ty Planning ;\<ivir.ocy C.o~..ission
Imb
*■
•s
TO: Otter Tail County Planning Advisory Ccxnmlssion
The undersigned, being property owners within the immediate adjoining
area of what is described as part of Government Lot Eight (8),
Section Three (3), Township 132, Range 39, the area Southwest and
adjacent to Mallard Bay Resort, on Stuart Lake, being Lake No.
56-191, Section 3, Township 132, Range 39, in the Township of
Nidaros, Otter Tail County, Minnesota, do hereby register our
opposition to the application of Ruben F, Huber for a deviation
from the requirements of the Otter Tail County Shoreland Management
Ordinance so as to be permitted to construct and operate a 50
stallcamper-travel trailer facility in conjunction with Mallard
Bay Resort and we do hereby ask the Otter Tail County Planning
Advisory Commission to therefore deny said application for a
deviation*
•?
• -
• 'I ''
'-""'I
V.
>
. >
1
' -.- v
:
t
*.
m 'V;'•i
V''..«
^ Hi', fori
;;
i
;
K
SHORELAND MANAGEMENT
OTTER TAIL COUNTY
Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537
NOTICE OF HEARING FOR SPECIAL USE PERMIT
NOTICE OF HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR DEVIATION FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF
THE- SHORELAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, OTTER TAIL COUNTY, MINNESOTA.
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
Ruben F. Huber
811-7th Street N.W.
Faribault, Minnesota 55021
has made application to the Otter Tail County Planning Advisory Commission for a Deviation from the
requirements of the Otter Tail County Shoreland Management Ordinance. The Otter Tail County Plan
ning Advisary Commission will assemble for this hearing on 19 71Decambaj- 1
Fergus Falls, Minnesota.«:nn M. Place.Time.r.niirt. House
Use South Door
The property concerned in the application is legally described as:
^32 RangeSec.__3Lake No. 56-191 NidarosTwp. Name.
Part of Government Lot 8, Section 3, Township 132, Range 39.
Area is Southwest and adjacent to Mallard Bay Resort.
On Stuart Lake, a Recreational Development Lake.
Twp.
THE PURPOSE OF THE APPLICATION IS:
Construct and operate a fifty (50) stall camper-travel trailer facility
in conjunction with Mallard Bay Resort,
water and sewage service will not be available (Dependent sites).
Included in plan is a 24 x 48 foot comfort station building where
water, shower and rest room accomodations will be located. Approximately
8 acres of land included in camper-travel trailer area.
Individual parking stall.
Dated Nnvpmbpr 14, 1971
Otter Tail County Planning Advisory Commission
By: Frank Alstadt, PresidentMKL-0871-011
(^ VICTOR LUNDECN L CO,. PRINTERS, FERGUS FALLS. UINn159034
PLANNING COMMISSION MOTIONS
i:^7iDEC 1Date
Situation;
It A'Motion
7
2nd By:
Voting:
' Yes . No ; AbstainAlstadt>-
Aho
HcirniT L
Beck
Christianson
Dillon
Fritz
Malmstrom
D. Nelson
H. Nelson
Revering
x:
21
X
V
2^.X
/1L_4Totals
Secretary’s Initials
Field Trip Research Report■4'
Re: Application for "Special Use Permit"
Developer; Ruben F. Huber, Faribault, Minnesota
For: Construct and operate a 50 stall camper-trailer facility in
conjunction with Mallard Bay Resort. See Copy of Hearing Notice.
Lake: Stuart, No. 56-191
Location: Nidaros Township
Township 132
Section 3 - Government Lot 8
Range 39
Lake Statistics: (as of 1967)
760 acres
7.5
Area:
Shore Miles;
Depth;
Dwellings;
Seasonal
Permanent
Resorts;
Dwelling p/mile; 7.3
Acres of water p/dwelling:
40
45
10
3
13.1
Mr. Huber has an option to buy Mallard Bay Resort and also the adjacent
land where camping areas will be located. (2 areas).
Worthington Realty, Fergus Falls is the agent for the seller.
The lake area under consideration is a very shallow portion of Stuart Lake.
In fact, 437„ (304 acres) of entire lake is less than 15 feet deep. Median
depth is 17 feet.
The lake has had extreme annual lake level fluctuations of about 3 feet. Aquatic
plant life is quite abundant in the lake consisting of bulrushes and submerged
pondweeds, bladderworst, yellow water lily, claspingleaf, etc.
Water color and turbidity are caused by algal bloom. Evidently this is not a
spring fed lake as a temperature test indicated there was only a difference of
one (1) degree between surface temperature and the temperature at a depth of
35 feet.
Neauscus is common on fish from this lake. (2 out of 3 perch and 4 out of 6
walleyes as per sample taken by Department of Natural Resources). The lake
is supporting large populations of largemouth bass and bluegills. The growth
rate of bluegills is slow. Heavy walleye stocking of this lake in past years
does not appear to have established a large walleye population. Carp are
present in the lake.
There are 35 platted lots on this peninsula with 75 foot frontage or less.
Current regulations require 150 feet of frontage. In the area of lot square
footage, the majority of the lots are less than 16,000 sq. feet and current
regulations require 40,000 sq. feet.
The proposed 50 stall trailer court, filled to capacity, would put more
pressure on the lake than the 35 platted lots on the entire peninsula.
Current road into the area from township road as shown is approximately
12 feet wide for first 1300 feet and 16 feet wide for next 600 feet up to
Ukkelberg property(Ukkelberg's own point of this peninsula). (See Oslund
preliminary copy of plat). There is no cul-de-sac at Ukkelberg property.
Note;
Information for parts of this report were taken from Fisheries Lake
Survey Report, Department of Natural Resources, dated July 8, 1960.
Malcolm K. Lee
11/29/71
i
\ ^\
‘
-?
r im/h:.
/
m%lA klAih
ilil
dA.ii J Aii;/Li A.'pt
IT ii.t-
//A-"'5 •••/ //I'i
i
I
5
•s
(
iK - -i
i
iI
X
':iK iIs
;|
-j
I
■i
.
W -K
A
:
*^ H ■,
j*:
lli.
'
'
.
:i
‘■
:
s
j
I
0
,■■
■
=
■s
•*
i
';
4
■
i
4
3
<
ill
•fi
I'>:
li I:•:>r.'W
1y.1
I/T .:IIX
n
*■
>;ir -1V
■11;■:
Iti
■j.
ti;:
.
rr
-;>c 4
J'
i‘7?
i
\ ' '. • . *’i . . '•- \ ' • • ’v • 4--" -.'•..W'V'’^'' .'.'a, '..\. ..V -.-
■ •' ■ ■ - N .. • .. •;;■ •' - • ..
>: ^ ^ >: ^ ^:-; ^ s ^
•4’:
%.IV,?i ■
A •.'i
.
X :■: :-: x ^ x ^ x x s x=x ^ x ^?Wx^ x =5= x ^x ^:-:’:-: :■: rx?: x =;x€ x m:" :•; x ;-:X -X - I I ;;• X ^ y. .1
:■;-- x=--xv- :.;?£=^x =-^virrr;x^x^x^x^:-;^ix?^x^::=^=?x = - x JSKiu
............................. :-:V,„'>r'i/
- '•*
'itf
-rJ -'.' • ,r" - .X-f .r; --
ii /1.*
- i"»
' "
< k'f 'i > t: i m-ffWk
TLmJ'S A~d"d iV I o Ki Op
|ylK'-\_K'^r^i ^ o n-'T
iai(hi'-/■*•*
i 'i-till tnc '
i ? «.A V.
'-1 *"i, ..■< ,i i
'X- .‘J Tf:
■■ ''.
t,‘ ;t*;.' I.'t
u {i _#'lili •'
*■ «
ar
liii ’
v" ^kT.:-'J %y0^!aliiii 4*"
i
» I *> *
£■ ■-
, "- E >
ilii
I
i. y*<-ijii ,V'vl»ter»- i■'rX 1>->^
I '-t#•
3,4 'Bvb^oiwi rt-'-iwVsS%iftxlpRvl|ISs - S.4.. xyyj:
=■ -r ^
..•■C,'-X ...
.. ..-':*'^‘!.,p-,Vr / '
. ^. X- " *
/'H.■i £.•IPi TAi-i Z ChBMJ^Ub'OfelV.)
i^yfIfl V FiS« C-i-v».»i't^*i
%
Zflin)' //|!'i m V*5
.(^-r ^ou-S^V
I I 3
P:i
%jy Xt'«>iiil "I #
aIiilkjumms'
-...
. •... ■"-' %
, X / f' ’S^.4>'r 3 ;3;.\
X*' V' -
8< 'f f i y
i'. . -A. ‘'f,
' ■*I 'I?»i»
-S’ T1/ A /P T ^*|y|
■} f ^
iiil
s,. -j, '.j ' '’X
til:
:•:
' -1-ilil!l »i•Xi T 6J A /P T
^isy-- I-.:
3?'* ' ■ ^
x' i, - - > k''^'. ,- I . < S.,: :.
i;il
CtAJT^AC SriOtA^ir^%l!!l
X Ti-t^uTo EMupiiafi,^ Yis 20'2.*/'ilM
SflouitR. i Ucrii-i'ryII .KMiill '*4Y Ii-;
X" *3 “X r“’
K:^iiH *1^
«Bii
: -34;;,
.fr
4 s'^■V-
' kI’X
■ .%l?i.''
, ■ '»Ma|B
I
,‘1
X '"'f'
Nil
Xi--44*f.>'Iiil
Z iX
r4
*
ill . '-1
x-f a5^:‘ 3
'“ ".5 v‘-* ^
.% :4f4g^3..
”3 4' ’'*■ *
:■:SiXm■ '>"1 t-ix.
I : r-
'' :V a^-f I
/j
if r„. .%• 3''‘ ■
».10
m^CZC?/(f /'Xr ::•:
' ^','. , tI'’’ •',
-' .t.WM'J & Y "
4. ^V ZX' '
X .'i'
N
” V' a p'-'c,
:-^-^;3-:S--3--
4,■:> f|
4 . ,-1 '»,-■•. , , 4 ;•-*, ‘?4
i-'i> ::'x?->-:..,;:v,->4:';;ri^j
"
«^«■17T
ffiiliX
^ ^'<siiiim *X
' --ifil “* a >
4‘. >• 4-. .. *
, 1 i "
V
f.
T;
I ■X I X
'■
X ' {«-■ K * *,3 - 4i
; ‘jr'' * '■ ,4. ifX-4.
p*l y ->•<i'X -§v
liM x:y-k< :Xfi4j-- K%, ;5'* - '®f ,'/"K 'SMi- '>hX
i! »*-'•' ’■I ^ Vi —KfT
• - //7cAi:0'/<fS . /770/?6/'^ tKo^//7c/ //7 yOA7e:K '
o- //ycZ/tra/^-y /rayy /?^o/7C/'^- . .
' /y/c^cec/ yy//A AxX/p/y, A/a. A:$'7dSr /4^/-(?a/7 ';
X ■AB
^m4:•:f
ZVVL45 Cih\rT2,(^L iWX
SAou^s.(2. 4, \JL*T»»-%“r»^ 3l"d6^,I f \IIff]'X-
X
i 'X,
X **N>Y IJ
X
Ml
;
X ^ :-2^ X s X s y. ^x ^ XX"^?^x;^x^^^x=: X ": X " X"
iHI
f i
\I V -111!i<"CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY
Robert B. Os lund and Associates
!i;j V
jir .0»^!S .A y‘:a M'-ft' .'i 4., 4III
_ill:•:REGISTERED LAND SURVEYORS.IV. C7>r. ^^c.^^ \
71a//:i /3239^'
s 1 !l|iN
OTTER TAIL COUNTY SURVEYORI'■h Iiil
ii TEL, 7364271
[ii I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS SURVEY, PLAN, OR REPORT WAS PREPARED BY ME OR UNDER M[
ii DIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT I AM A DULY REGISTERED LAND SURV^EYOR UNDER THE LAW
'■■ OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA.
im FERGUS FALLS COURT HOUSEN ■!iiiIPV'.■:I
V\“\
1!/ii f ■\I \i-1.I Iri
date //-A/kd.:■:
K ilEG. No. 7575
I’l
X4= V --—5 4a=S= -.- —-.- ..■:-: V: ^-... ^... ^... ^... ^... ^ V ^ V ^ X ^ X ^ X ^ X *;.: ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x ^ x « x ^ x=x ^ x=x ^ x ^ x ^ x x ^ x ^ x X 'i= X':-3^ ;■: ^ x x m'?>: ? ffx%sjv5=5= x Lss x ?■ Yss^f•_• -r-*.i ^hrt==?».• ' *—‘ft ■.• -r. “ ■=•_X = X « X ^ X = x ^ v ^ v v- ^ >: v s x x ^ x ^ x x ^ :■: ^ x ^ x x ^ x ^ x x s >: >: :< ^ >:» vs X