HomeMy WebLinkAbout17000200268000_Variances_08-11-20058'II-20C5 ,
982205 OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER
OTTER TAIL MINNESOTA
1 hereby certify that 9Q2205
this instrument #--------------------------
was filed/recorded in this office
for record on the—Lj—day of
2005
. Mefcalf,,Cpu^ RWend
U ^COr/^^liecord^na f^/
^ well certifirate
ler
THE ABOVE SPACE IS RESERVED FOR THE COUNTY RECORDER
APPLiCATiON FOR VARIANCE
COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL
GOVERNMENT SERVICES CENTER
540 WEST FIR, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537
(218) 998-8095
Otter Tail County’s Website: www.co.ottertail.mn.us
Application Fee
rnsm.COMPLETE THIS APPLICATION IN BLACK INK Receipt Number
Accepted By / Date -i I r
DAYTIME PHONE \ ^ ' 3 SPri&e nPROPERTY OWNER I irv-^
L-cx^ K ^-*'3 3 ^
RANGE ^ TOWNSHIP NAME L> ^ n V\
MAILING ADDRESS
jei)LAKE CLASSLAKE NAMELAKE NUMBER
SECTION ^ 0 TOWNSHIP t 37
E-911
ADDRESS
PARCEL
NUMBER ^3C "7 (r- K guR- / ICbCdOO ^ <c8000
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
, pfC
Lc-r /a
Q~c c T~ L~c~^ ^
to"T
TYPE OF VARIANCE REQUESTED (Please Check)
Structure Setback Structure Size ClusterSewage System Subdivision Misc.
SPECIFY VARIANCE REQUESTED ^ JL V t or'oTi Y\ ^. ss • c Yi Xi p la.c&r i
Tl\ c yie- a ^ A ^ tc c c Yt -dv T~• o Yv i •’v
pt''
A./I fc>«-L-xPC.cc'X.'CYi.
^ ccY'✓'<> vtT* fcOnJT-ev'w'-e I of-'
^ y T k-co
f-eeX- ^
/bo\
S A. Yvi e..tna.
yc> rr\fi\C,
\ ^ e € T -h~0~ C- c s
/fL r T-e. ‘A S *■"i’y ko.c, p(jLCC.^i'c^\irtc 1® CcldS <? v"
I UNDERSTAND THAT I HAVE APPLIED FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE SHORELAND
MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE/SUBDIVISION CONTROLS ORDINANCE OF OTTER TAIL COUNTY.
I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED, IT IS MY RESPONSIBILITY TO CONTACT LAND &
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT REGARDING THIS MATTER.
SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER DATE
APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT THE HEARING(Applicant Will Receive Notification As To The Date/Time Of Hearing)
cl T/vTs c CJL ^ ^ 2> w
Ut is ^ s sTa.nd«^<r i
i^/ 'I C
rce-o^X.
/ //!TimeDate Of Hearing
Motion
Eugene and Karen Prim - Approved the variance as modified with a condition. (8:26 p.m.)
After discussion and consideration, Paul Larson made a motion, second by Cecil Femling to approve the variance as
requested with the following conditions: 1.) no more than 25% of the total lot area can be covered with impervious
surfaces as determined by the Land and Resource Department, 2.) no other variance can be granted for the proposed
development, and 3.) the proposed development can be no closer to the ordinary high water level than the existing
structure, The motion failed with Rod Boyer, Randall Mann and Steve Schierer voting no.
After additional consideratio^and discussion, SteveSchiefermade a motibn, second by Rod Boyer and unanimously
carried, to appro^develo^ent no cIpsefTS the ordinary high water leveHhan what would be permitted by the
applicatiop'of the sWng line test wi^
and with/the coAditionlhat no more t is a substand^
her vari^ndes for the proposed development are granted
j£^aMjTh^overed with impervious surfaces. Hardship
he^eon^W^ that
idp^'2^"(5ttroedtdf:al lot
Chairman/Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment
Permit(s) required from Land & Resource Management
Yes (Contact Land & Resource Management) (/,X iMAhyoid.No
Copy of Application Mailed to Applicant, Co. Assessor and the MN DNR
L R Official/Date
bk 0903r001
315,694 • Victor Lundeen Co., Primers • Fergus Falls. Minnesota
August I i, 2005
Page # 3
John A and Joanne A Molstre - Denied. (7:40 p.m.)
John A and Joanne A Molstre, Lot 11 Olson's'North Shore and part of Government Lot 5, Section 2 of
Eagle Lake Township by Eagle Lake, requested a variance of 45’ from the required ordinary high water
level setback of 75’ and a variance of 8.5’ from the required shore impact zone setback of 37.5’ for the
enclosure of two existing porch areas and a. variance of 3’ from the required side lot line setback of 10’ for
an addition to the north side of the existing .structureT’ from the lot line. The applicants noted that they are
no longer requesting the side lot line variance of 3’; The audience was polled with no one speaking for or
against the variance as requested. After discussion and consideration, Rod Boyer made a motion, second
by Cecil Femling and carried with Paul Larson and MichaerCbnIon voting no, to deny the variance as
requested as no adequate hardship unique to the property had been shown that would allow for the
granting of the variance as requested and the proposed development on the lakeside of the cabin is within
the shore impact zone.
Patrick and Kathleen Skelly - Approved the variance as requelsted. (7:50 p.m.)
Patrick and Kathleen Skelly, part of Government Lot 10, Section 26 of Candor Township by Loon Lake,
requested a variance of 73’ from the required ordinary hjgh water level setback of 100’ and a variance of
, 23’ from the required shore impact zone setback of 50’ for the repair of an existing building located 27’ from
the ordinary high water level, a variance of 59' from the required ordinary high water level setback of 100’
and a variance of 9’ from the required shore impact zone setback of 50’ for an addition to an existing
structure 41 ’ from the ordinary high water level and a variance of 25’ from the required setback of 75’ for
the placement of a septic holding tank 50’ from the ordinary high water level. The audience was polled with
no one speaking for or against the variance as requested. A letter from Mary and Tim Wieben in support of
the variance as requested was read for the record. After discussion and consideration, Cecil Femling
made a motion, second by Rod Boyer and carried with Steve Schierer voting no, to approve the variance
as requested and as depicted on the drawing submitted with the variance application. Hardship is the
terrain and topography of the applicants’property.
Mark H and Kathryn R Biederman - Approved the variance as modified with a condition. (8:12 p.m.)
Mark H and Kathryn R Biederman, part of Lot 14 and all of Lot 15 Camp Tynset, South Ten Mile Lake in
Tumuli Township, requested a variance of 15’ and a variance of 12’ from the required roadTight-of-way
setback of 20’ for the placement of one corner of the proposed-24’ by 32’ garage/dwelling 8’ from the road
right-of-way and for the placement of the other corner of the proposed 24’ by 32’ garage/dwelling 5’ from
the road right-of-way. A letter from Tumuli Township requesting a setback of 22’ from the edge of the
existing blacktop was read for the record. A letter from Tony and Judith Rivera in support of the variance
as requested was read for the record. The audience was polled with no one speaking for or against the
.variance as requested.. After discussion and consideration, Cecil Femling made a motion, second by Rod
Boyer and unanimously carried, to approve the placement of the proposed 24’ by 32’ garage/dwelling 22’
from the existing blacktop with the condition that access to the garage must be from the lot and not directly
from the road. Hardship is the terrain of the'applicants’ property.
Eugene and Karen Prim - Approved the variance as modified with a condition. (8:26 p.m.)
Eugene and Karen Prim, part of Government Lot 3, Section 20 of Dunn Township by Lake Lizzie,
requested a variance of 76’ from the required ordinary high water level setback of 100’ and a variance of
27’ from the required shore impact zone setback of 50’ for the replacement of an existing dwelling with a
new structure 24’ from the ordinary high water leveL the audience was polled with no one speaking for or
against the variance as requested. An email from James Bruggeman and from John and Judy Gunkelman
in support of the variance as requested was.iread for the record.- After discussion and consideration, Paul
Larson made a motion, second by Cecil Femling to approve the variance as requested with the following
conditions; 1.) no more than 25% of the total lot area can be covered with impervious surfaces as
determined by the Land and Resource Department, 2.) no other variance can be granted for the proposed
development, and 3.) the proposed development can be no closer to the ordinary high water level than the
existing structure. The motion failed with Rod Boyer, Randall Mann and Steve Schierer voting no.
..
■1}
August 11, 2005
Page # 4
Eugene and Karen Prim - Approved as modified with conditions. (8:26 p.m. - continued)
After additional consideration and discussion, Steve Schierer made a motion, second by Rod Boyer and
unanimously carried, to approve development no closer to the ordinary high water level than what would be
permitted by the application of the string line test with the condition that no, other variances for the
proposed development are granted and with the condition that.no more than 25% of the total lot area can
be covered with impervious surfaces; Hardship is a substandard lot of record.
Eric and Tami Malmstrom - Approved.the Variance as requested. (8:54 p.m.)
Eric and Tami Malmstrom, Lot 17 Martee Beach, Blanche Lake in Everts Township, requested a variance
of 24’ from the required ordinary high water level setback of 100’ to change a roof line from a 2/12 to a 5/12
and from a 5/12 to a 10/12 and to extend the roof line to cover a 10.5’ by 19.5’ open area located 76’ from
the ordinary high water level. The audience was polled with no one speaking for or against the variance as
requested. Letters from Lowell and Eileen Larson, Fred and Kathy Rizk and G. Richard Vinton in support
of the variance as requested were read for the record. After discussion and consideration, Steve Schierer
made a motion, second by Michael Conlon and unanimously carried, to approve a variance of 24’ from the
required ordinary high water level setback of 100’ to change a roof line from a 2/12 to a 5/12 and from a
5/12 to a 10/12 and to extend the roof line to cover a 10.5’. by 19.5’ open area located 76’ from the ordinary
high water level. The Board noted that the proposed project is within the general building line. The Board
also noted that the well will need to be relocated to comply with existing code.
With no further business, Randall Mann, Chairman declared the meeting adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
Wayne St^ t. Secretary
z
ITv<ooVT•7Q_
%
vTzoozILIUJ>
h-<tuOin'<
Q Q;OLD HIGHWAY #59OLD HIGHWAY #59
cvclU
■|ztj
SS<
Hi
-§50
"^Uj o
'»=^u_ .1^ S
o iC -f*
C
♦ , *>•► • ®* 5f c
Zt
5 Li I
Tsaer frqper’y lj€75^0 PROPERTY LINE
PROPDSED PLAN
EXISTING PLAN
ISTEEP HILL
ALL GREEN SPACESTEEP HLL
ALL GREEN SPACE
IIII
OZooIolA<
0000 f
GRAVEL SERVICE ROAD APPROX. WIDTH 12' APPROX. 85.eB3' FROM LAKE
IIIIGRAVEL SERVICE ROAD
APPROX. WDTH 12'h-lUCOVERAGESLUto p- to®-?
<50^
Z»—4
_J <_1 BUILDINGS = 876 SO. FT.
DECK = 442 SO. FT.
CONCRETE = 465 SO. FT.:r-• < o.f
UJ o>-.E>a. I ^
UJ ' CL EXIST.issALe^
■SE PTIC
I aIUJcn83/ZCLUJUJ TOTAL COVERAGE = 1.783 SO. FT.
TOTAL LOT = U2S0 SO. FT.t a.z M X 14- STORAGE SHED
10- X 14- STORAGE SHED
is_J §/C3UJ>-(S§OPEN SPACE = 9.467 SO. FT. TOTAL USED = 15%
u m<CL CL II' 83 I UJ
z 14.50 24.00'UJUJCL§§GREEN SPACEGREEN SPACEa OcsaOPROPOSED
CABIN
24 X 26
•r!EXISTING
CABIN
14 X 20
ZII'.SOICnI LUiTv
10.50'tOv
c<A
<
V ^
< tr
LU o
= EXISTING
^SLM PORCH
= 8 X 14-
= EXISTING
^SUN PORCH
= 8T X 14-II
LEGAL DESCRPTION
OSECT.-20 / TWP-137 / RANGE-042
O zEAST HALF LOT 12 AND ALL OF LOT 13 GOVT. LOT 3 LAKE LIZZE OTTERTAL COLNTY
O lU tu
v£5 V
3 <
o rOvN-oUCYtC\Sf-j:v'St.
lU z IPARCEL ID RI7000200268000
O
^ 5:
o ^(Cl ^ c>J
rr Cvl
LU^ >N, ✓S, W >*Vvv yv _y\^ >v >v ys^ >*N. y\.
75.00' PROPERTY LINE75:00* PROPERTY LINE
d CD a:> z LU
JT) QLU I
cvj I\IN 'TL-LPi>- tuzX •> -LU j' cOZ(C\ V)
CT ^5U £S
m cngS
_i^9
. 03
j:::\G9rH9ral CBdd\Gxcf\f^tMCAB/N.gxd 07/14/2005 09.34 AM - Scai^ 1 48 00.
Wayne Stein - EUGENE & KAREN PRIM VARIANCE Page 1
"Jim Bruggeman" <jimb@corwinauto.com>
<wstein@co.ottertail.mn.us>
8/1/05 1:32PM
EUGENE & KAREN PRIM VARIANCE
From:
To:
Date:
Subject:
MR. STEIN
I HAVE A CABIN AT 23064 WASHBURN LANE, WHICH IS NEXT TO THE PRIM'S TO THE WEST.
GENE HAS SHOWN ME HIS PRELIMINARY PLANS FOR HIS CABIN IMPROVEMENTS. WE HAVE
ALSO DISCUSSED THEM AT LENGTH AND WALKED OUR PROPERTIES VISUALIZING THE
IMPROVEMENTS. I HAVE NO PROBLEMS OR CONCERNS WITH THE PRIM'S IMPROVEMENT
PLANS. I DON'T SEE HOW THE IMPROVEMENTS WOULD HAVE ANY ADVERSE AFFECT ON MY
PROPERTY OR ANY OF THE OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE AREA. THE PLANS APPEAR TO BE
VERY MODEST AND SHOULD FIT IN JUST FINE.
IF YOU HAVE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS OF MY OR YOU WOULD LIKE ANY MORE
INFORMATION, FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ME.
JAMES BRUGGEMAN
3317 VILLAGE GREEN DRIVE
MOORHEAD, MN 56560
701-388-2082
Wayne Stein - RE: Variance request for 8-11-05 Page 1
"JUDY A. GUNKELMAN" <gunkelj@fargo.k12.nd.us>
<wstein@co.ottertail.mn.us>
8/9/05 9:09AM
RE: Variance request for 8-11-05
From:
To:
Date:
Subject:
RE: Karen and Eugene Primm
Variance request at 23076 Washburn Lane
Lake Lizzie
As immediate neighbors to the east of Karen and Eugene Primm on Lake
Lizzie, we support their request for a variance regarding the required set
back and also for the variance regarding the shore impact zone.
Sincerely,
John and Judy Gunkelman
1510 7th St. So.
Fargo, ND 58103
701-235-0854
gunkelj@fargo.k12.nd.us
--■r
2
<o y
r)Q_
I£s
Z
>iD&52gQQQ_
OLD HIGHWAY #59OLD HIGHWAY #59A-
(UlU
V.
i>;i
?S0ff PROPERTY Ln^75B0' PROPERTY LINE
PROPOSED PLAN
m1“P^;
C“
i3>
si-S§ri§
il*§
S11EP WLL ALL GREEN SPACE
I
bbbZI5ID<50 50
• APPROX WIDTH \Z . APPROX Baaff L^,
is' ti_
uj’COVERAGES ,o <V)BUiLDIMS ■ 078 SQ FT.a >IpCi_8i
I TOTAL COVERAGE - L7B3 SQ FT. TOTAL LOT - a250 SQ FT.
CPEN ^ACE - a467 SQ FT.
TOTAL I SEP • 15X3-ED - - •
O
i I
■
.0)1..I4.50l
- Z4.00'36.50-§
[V 4GREEN SPACE0 [yb o03PROPOSED5bzICABIN
24 X S Itr>iIT\rtS LJJ I .I0.50-
Cy ■
'"■
■ ^<5.V ^ ■
Q <
•aAD
oZ5< bLEGAL DESCRPnCN oSECT.-2B / TVP-13F / RAACE-042 U15liJ O^ w
aD V
3 <
UJ J
EAST HALF LOT 12 Aid ALL
OF LOT 13 GOVT. LOT 3 AKE LIZZIE TTERTAIL COJTTY0
I
PARCQ. ID
5 sLlI
7Sea PROPERTY LINE T5.00’ PROPERTY LINE __I (n CL (G ^ 5><> zyQZ
^ ^hJ ^ ? 5
CL ^ E ^
<C 03 b {Q
A^'1^^UJ
BARNESVILLE
PHONE: (218) 354-2606
FAX; (218) 354-2246
E-MAIL: rcrdrvw@rrl.nel,P-0. BOX 70 -424 FRONT STREET SOUTH
BARNESVILLE, MN 56514-0070
r-7
yy'
z A/"7 y)1
/C) /A
/f^Ap X /
f 7-fS^fr
fyAT /r /77"p/?Y/ji/rpT/PP-aO-T7
P'fc)^^ pfP ^/7pp,
yyt-i J4Ppfch'fp pppp/..('6"
yppA' p///pp pppyy/y J/Ayrt)-y1S7Z
/p- py
AA/
'Over 100 Years
f
106
\.
'A
t
\A.
s.
//
V-
-e;
5^4
12.
Ak’F I \~7~71
Notice of Hearing for Variance
Otter Taii County
Government Services Center
510 Fir Ave W
Fergus Falls, MN 56537
(218) 998-8030/998-8041
Email - wstein@co.ottertail.mn.us
www.co.otter-tail.mn.us
Applicant must be present at the scheduled hearing.
To Whom It May Concern:
Eugene and Karen Prim
602 9"^ St SE
PO Box 70
Barnesville, MN 56514
has made application to the Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment for a variance as per requirements of the Otter Tail
County Shoreland Management Ordinance, the Otter Tail County Set Back Ordinance and/or the Subdivision Controls
Ordinance. The Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment will assemble for this hearing on
Thursday, August 11, 2005 at 7:30 p.m..
in the Commissioners’ Room of the Otter Tail County Government Services Center, Fergus Falls, MN. (Please use the
public entrance located on the northeasterly side of the Government Services Center. The second left off Fir Ave.)
Individuals requiring special accommodations shouid contact the County Auditor’s office prior to the date of
the public hearing.
The property concerned in the application is legally described as
East Half of Lot 12 and all of Lot 13 of Government Lot 3,
Property Address - 23076 Washburn Lane
Section 20, Township 137, Range 42 - Township Name - Dunn
Lake No. 56-760, Lake Name - Lizzie, Ciass - RD
The variance requested is -
a variance of 76’ from the required ordinary high water level setback of 100’ and a variance of 27’ from the
required shore impact zone setback of 50’ for the replacement of an existing dwelling with a new structure
24’ from the ordinary high water level.
Wayne Stein
Board of Adjustment Secretary
Date: July 15, 2005