HomeMy WebLinkAbout13000990279000_Variances_08-01-1973White — Office
Yellow — Owner
Pink — Township
APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE
FROM
^ Requirements of Shoreland Management Ordinances Otter Tail County, Minnesota
Phone No.Owner:
Last N MiddleFirstame
7>v^.P-r /State Zip No.Street 8i No.
P'T'-DaJj Lake ClassLake NameLegal Description: Lake No.,7^'/ A Li1IRangeTwp. Name.Sec.Twp.
/^o-otn
€Sdl
If applicant is a corporation, what state incbrporate^in____________________0.___^---------------
Applicant is;^Sv^) Owner ( ) Lessee
7 -t
( ) Agent( ) Occupant
List Partner's name and address below:Is Applicant a partnership.
ves or no
NAME, ADDRESS AND ZIP NO.NAME, ADDRESS AND ZIP NO.
This application for deviation is from Shoreland Management Ordinance, Otter Tail County, Minnesota for conditons found in
what Section of the Ordinance:_____
EXPLAIN YOUR PROBLEM HERE: . . ,
4^ C7\.>4..JL 'Xfc L-Vv-' OrTCD
(X^Jl pCouCx^ l/ ^ - !aJ>
uO Cnj^—Stb /}C>
In order to properly evaluate the situation, please provide as miren supplementary information as possible, such as: maps,
plans, information about surrounding property, etc.
7-
19.Application dated.dT"AppllcantST?n
—DO NOT USE SPACE BglOW—
19^
Date application filed with Shoreland Management Administration,
Deviation requires: Planning Commmission approval ( ) Shoreland Management approval only { ) BoTiHJ )
ByFiling acknowledgement
__ signature,—.
/Kv.,
Date, time and place of hearing
<ZnJ 0^y(jJo~t~ 19 75nW!TH THE FOLLOWINGDEVIATION APPROVED this______
(OR ATTACHED) REOU!REMENTS:
day of
a.^LA^y'-e-^
GupxyD/Lou^-^<Q
^ /v OMLiLvv^S^t.
F rank Alstadt, PfSiidow»-
Signature.
Otter Tail Planning Advisory Commission
Deviation
Approved this AaA ijL7rt~ m 7^ By.X //_/i .-ee^__
Malcolm K. Lee, Shoreland Management Adminj^tgtor^
Otter Tall County, Minnesota
day of.
MKL-0871 016
v'cro* \.uMDECN 4 CO ‘’•iHTERi. rritsus r«Li.l. hihm.
159079
GRIP PLOT PLAN SKETCHING FORM _.feet/inches.ScaleEach grid equals
Application for Building Permit Dated.
Application for Sewage System Permit Dated
.19 II^-istt
.19
+-fSewage System Permit Number.Building Permit Number
Applicant agrees that this plot plan is a part of application (s) indicated above.-J-
i
19.Dated Signature
■ !..
lO
t-
i;
_^.4.t !I
Id • I
V.. ,t TT
-ri_L. ^ : _U I -
IldT i
ii
4.
-1-
4-
T
u«n > i luKiiif*1104^iiintA.lteiiEiNuSrwi
:.^_d4-
I M I N N E 5 0 T A I
MDHl2m99^a?9i?/!>0
5Ip-(p5^received
Protecting, maintaining and improving the health of all Minnesotans ^ 3 2011
land & RESOURCE
IDEPARTMENTofHEALTHI
May 11,2011
Refer to: License Number 1489 (TN 4698)
Mr. Gary Auseth
Fergus Well Company
1925 County Highway 111
Fergus Falls, Minnesota 56537
Mr. Dale Basehore
P.O. Box 48
Kent, Minnesota 56553
Dear Mr. Falk and Mr. Basehore:
Subject: Variance from Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4725, for Construction of a Water-Supply
Well, Minnesota Unique Well Number 752972, on the Dale Basehore Property at
24946 Wall Lake Point Circle, Located in the NE Va of the SW 14 of Section 4,
Township 132 North, Range 42 West, Dane Prairie Township, Otter Tail County,
Minnesota_________________________________________
This letter is in response to your request for a variance from Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4725,
to construct a water-supply well on the subject property, 33 feet from an untested buried sewer
on the subject property, 40 feet from an untested buried sewer on the neighboring property to the
west, and 30 feet from the ordinary high-water level of Wall Lake.
Minnesota Rules, part 4725.4450, subpart 1, item E requires that a water-supply well must be
located at least 50 feet from a buried sewer. Minnesota Rules, part 4725.4450, subpart 1, item G
does allow a well to be located a minimum of 20 feet from a buried sewer that serves one
building or two or less single family residences and is constructed of cast-iron or plastic pipe that
meets the materials and pressure testing specifications of Mirmesota Rules, parts 4715.0530 and
4715.2820 (Minnesota Plumbing Code), provided that the sewer is not a collector or municipal
sewer and does not serve a facility handling infectious or pathological waste. Minnesota Rules,
part 4725.4350, subpart 1 requires that a water-supply well must be a minimum horizontal
distance of 35 feet from the ordinary high-water level of a stream, river, pond, storm water
retention pond, or lake.
On April 22, 2011, Mr. Jeffrey Grugel, district hydrologist with the Minnesota Department of
Health (MDH) Fergus Falls district office, met with Mr. Gary Auseth of Fergus Well Company
and inspected the subject property. Mr. Grugel reported that there is no location for a well on the
property that satisfies all of the isolation requirements of Minnesota rules. The proposed well
location identified in the variance request application appears to provide the greatest practicable
separation from the known potential contamination sources and hazards.
The variance application indicates that the proposed well would be constructed by the rotary
drilling method to an estimated depth of 60 feet. The well would have 56 feet of 4-inch diameter
polyvinyl chloride (PVC) well casing, and the annular space surrounding the casing would be
filled with bentonite grout.
General Information: 651-201-5000 • Toll-free: 888-345-0823 • TTY: 651-201-5797 •www.health.state.mn.us
An equal opportunity employer
Mr. Gary Auseth
Mr. Dale Basehore
Page 2
May 11,2011
Mr. Grugel was informed that the existing well on the subject property had failed and was in
need of replacement. In order to accommodate the timely replacement of the water supply,
Mr. Grugel explained to Mr. Auseth the conditions under which a variance would be granted and
did provide verbal approval on May 5, 2011, to allow drilling to begin.
Based on Mr. Grugel’s inspection, information provided in the variance request, and in
accordance with Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4725, a variance is hereby granted to Mr. Dale
Basehore and Fergus Well Company for construction of a new water-supply well,
Minnesota Unique Well Number 752972, 33 feet from an untested buried sewer on the
subject property, 40 feet from an untested buried sewer on the neighboring property to the
west, and 30 feet from the ordinary high-water level of Wall Lake at 24946 Wall Lake
Point Circle, Fergus Falls, Minnesota. The variance is granted because there is no accessible
location for a well on the subject property that complies with all required isolation distances. The
proposed well location appears to provide the greatest practicable separation between the well
and known potential contamination sources.
Because the isolation distances between the proposed well and the buried sewers and lake is less
than required in rule, additional construction methods and precautions are required in order to
reduce the potential for contamination of the well and groundwater. The following list of
additional conditions and requirements should provide the necessary additional protection for the
well and groundwater.
The variance is granted with the following conditions:
You must contact Mr. Grugel at 218/332-5148 at least 24 hours prior to beginning well
construction so that arrangements for inspection during well construction may be made.
1.
The well casing for the proposed well must extend to a depth of at least 50 feet and
penetrate at least 10 feet of clay or sandy clay material.
2.
3.The annular space between the well casing and the bore hole wall must be filled with
neat-cement grout, cement-sand grout, or bentonite grout as defined in Minnesota Rules,
part 4725.0100. Bentonite grout must be a mixture of water and a minimum of 15 percent by
weight powdered or granular bentonite that is NSF approved, must be designed by the
manufacturer as a well sealant or grout, and must be mixed to the manufacturer's
specifications. Grout must be inserted through the casing or through a tremie pipe from
within 10 feet of the bottom of the casing up to the ground surface or base of the pitless
connection.
The disposal of drilling mud, cuttings, treatment chemicals, and discharged water must be in
accordance with applicable state and local regulations. Suitable containment or temporary
erosion control measures must be provided so that contaminants do not enter the lake.
4.
Mr. Gary Auseth
Mr. Dale Basehore
Page 3
May 11,2011
5. The existing well on the subject property must be permanently sealed by a Minnesota
licensed well contractor or licensed well sealing contractor in accordance with Minnesota
Rules, Chapter 4725, within 30 days after completion of the new well.
6. All other provisions of Minnesota Rules, Chapter 4725, are in effect.
Mr. Grugel was on the site on May 9, 2011, during completion of the well construction.
Mr. Grugel was informed that the water-bearing formation that was expected at a depth of
60 feet, based on a construction record for a neighboring well, was not encountered. Instead, the
well was drilled to a depth of 140 feet, with 136 feet of 4-inch PVC well casing and 4 feet of
stainless steel screen. The annular space was grouted with bentonite grout from a depth of
126 feet up to the ground surface.
Alternative measures or conditions attached to a variance have the force of law and effect of
applicable rule. If a party violates the alternative measures or conditions attached to the variance,
the party is subject to enforcement actions and penalties provided in the applicable law or rule.
This variance is conditioned upon the applicable acceptance of and compliance with the
conditions of the variance. Failure by the applicant to comply with the conditions prescribed in
the variance will result in the immediate expiration of the variance.
If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Grugel at 218/332-5148 or Mr. Ed Schneider at
651/201-4595.
Sincerely,
Linda B. Bruemmer, Director
Environmental Health Division
P.O. Box 64975
St. Paul, Minnesota 55164-0975
LBBiJG'.dg
cc; Bill Kalar, Otter Tail County Land and Resource Management