The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About16000990461000_Variances_04-14-2011v-yy--?<9 // lilliilEi1091041DOC# 1091041 1C91041 Fee: $46 00 Well Certificate [ ] Rec'd OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER OTTER TAIL COUNTY MINNESOTA Certified. Filed, and/or Recorded Aoril 20 2011 9,15 AM Wendy L. Metcalf, Recorder Returned To: LAND & RESOURCE By: NDB THE ABOVE SPACE IS RESERVED FOR THE COUNTY RECORDER APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL GOVERNMENT SERVICES CENTER 540 WEST FIR, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537 (218) 998-8095 Otter Tail County’s Website: www.co.ottertail.mn.us Application Fee COMPLETE THIS APPLICATION IN BLACK INK Receipt Number . ^ Accepted By / Date Ml AKipeeu t I g/ikiKiF /ZOZ- 3Hn S-h ^ '70/-DAYTIME PHONEPROPERTY OWNER o Ajr> ^/03MAILING ADDRESS LAKE CLASSLAKE NUMBER LAKE NAME TOWNSHIPH-y.I30>DoPMRANGETOWNSHIP NAMESECTION PARCEL NUMBER E-911 ADDRESS 33^7^3 LEGAL DESCRIPTION 5-1 i 3Z 3U>CK I , [AJe^3t M / TYPE OF VARIANCE REQUESTED (Please Check) Cluster Misc.Structure Setback Structure Size Sewage System Subdivision SPECIFY HOW YOUR PROJECT VARIES FROM ORDINANCE REQUIREMENTS. PLEASE BE BRIEF AS THIS WILL BE USED FOR PUBLIC NOTIFICATION. I UNDERSTAND THAT I HAVE APPLIED FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE SHORELAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE/SUBDIVISION CONTROLS ORDINANCE OF OTTER TAIL COUNTY. I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED, IT IS MY RESPONSIBILITY TO CONTACT LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT REGARDING THIS MATTER. SIGNATURE Of"^r6pERT r DATEWNER / AGENT FOR OWNER APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT THE HEARING(Applicant Will Receive Notification As To The Date/Time Of Hearing) ¥ V- /V- //Date Of Hearing Time Motion Andrew & Leanne Magnotto - Approved the application as requested with a condition. (8:26 p.m.) After consideration and discussion, Randall Mann made a motion, second by Steve Schierer and unanimously carried, to approve the variance as requested and as depicted on the drawing submitted with the application with the condition that no portion of the proposed development can be within 50’ of West McDonald Lake. It was also noted that the variances as approved do not directly or indirectly grant any other variances than those outlined in the request. Hardship/practical difficulty is substandard lots of record and lakes on two sides of the property. TrmanTOtter Tail CoullTy^oarcl ofi^justment Permit(s) required from Land & Resource Management X Yes (Contact Land & Resource Management) \ -..'ti No Copy of Application Mailed to Applicant, Co. Assessor and the MN DNR L R Official/Date bk 0407-001 329,512 - Victor Lundeen Company, Fergus Falls, Minnesota Notice of Hearing for Variance Otter Tail County Government Services Center 510 Fir Ave W Fergus Falls, MN 56537 (218) 998-8030/998-8041 Email - wstein@co.ottertail.mn.us www.co.otter-tail.mn.us Applicant and/or appiicant’s representative must be present at the scheduled hearing. To Whom It May Concern: Andrew and Leanne Magnotto 1202 8*^ StS Fargo, ND 58103 has made application to the Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment for a variance as per requirements of the Otter Tail County Shoreland Management Ordinance, the Otter Tail County Set Back Ordinance and/or the Subdivision Controls Ordinance. The Otter Tail County Board of Adjustment will assemble for this hearing on .m.j in the Commissioners’ Room of the Otter Tail County Government Services Center, Fergus Falls, MN. (Please use the public entrance located on the northeasterly side of the Government Services Center. The second left off Fir Ave.) Individuals requiring special accommodations should contact the County Auditor’s office prior to the date of the public hearing. The property concerned in the application is legally described as Lots 51 and 52 Block 1 Crystal Beach, Property Address - 33453 Charlie Trapp Rd Section 24, Township 136, Range 41 - Township Name - Dora Lake No. 56-386/1628, Lake Name - West McDonald/Brown, Class - RD/NE The variance requested is -I the following: Requesting to replace the roof on the existing 20' by 28’ structure. The proposed replacement will be in the same footprint. The existing pitch of the roof is 6:12 and will be replaced by a 12:12 pitch roof. Requesting to replace existing 16’ by 10’ deck, which is currently 36’ from the ordinary high water level and other impervious surfaces on property with a new 14’ by 16’ covered deck approximately 48’ from the ordinary high water level. Replacement would decrease the impervious surface from 13.7% to 12.8%. The proposed replacement project will be approximately 48’ back from the ordinary high water level on West McDonald Lake and 35’ back from ordinary high water level on Brown Lake. Requesting a 52’ setback variance from the ordinary high water level on West McDonald and 165’ setback variance from ordinary high water level on Brown Lake. The current structure is approximately 8’ from the alley. Proposed project will not change location. Current shed is approximately 3’ from the alley, 23’ from Brown Lake and 75’ from West McDonald Lake. Proposing to replace roof on existing structure. Requesting setback variance of 177’ from Brown Lake and 25’ variance from West McDonald. Location of shed will not be changed. Shed is 10’ from holding tank. Stein Board of Adjustment Secretary Date: March 17,2011 5-iteta (jiseutos HAififjnt* LAi4£ttD)yie 13T 9) + 9Z- ,&U?4J<.1, CP>(^u mHM i r!<• I \ as4TPf4EWBfl)F@^5ttBD /I 'I'l ii;'j1iMlli-i; %iiiiid IJ lli n3E D m;uHB o= cxiSTit'lfe r?eft3FL->« ■1 n!femra GiJ1111I dvr.ZT-Tld-G l^Ifl 6XfcVrtT)P>J ‘js>'--l'-cD‘'u ii WesT Etev/>VT7PHCr+ » ISB fivUiVtnffl Asi —A-I [- r I ;1 'U-A LiiE/ereuvMioH _ axTTH BlisVwnoH ^V-cp*■l It-7 I-rH- h . \ V : \iifo25 /7 ;; 1 /T ■[ : ‘T.:tfe>fo5eo -f^|2cvy'hlEW pst.a ■■Sr ; ; I il h' +-t e;7\\f • “MAH Ft<aa<af'rJ 112J.lc7 uwmiA \;t 'xr:.|HB0 c»i<Me«,/e<w^../,Ir--~ / I ISEH s>-to€ “ ”,t9£M(>-te «BT1 te>--I i -Hi CURRENT IMPERVIOUS SURFACE: house - 560 sq.ft deck - 264 sq.ft sidewalk - 54 sq.ft shed - 96 sq.ft TOTAL= 978 SQUARE FEET PROPOSED IMPERVIOUS SURFACE; house - 560 sq. ft ftont & side stoop- 32 sq. ft screen porch - 224 sq. ft shed-96 sq.ft TOTAL = 912 SQUARE FEET IMPERVIOUS SURFACE REDUCED BY 66 SQUARE FEET TOTAL AREA OF PROPERTY = 7125 SQ. FT CURRENT AMOUNT OF IMPERVIOUS SURFACE = 13.7% PROPOSED AMONUT OF IMPERVIOUS:SURFACE = 12:8% 3jn/2^// \- & FILE MEMO & PARCEL # Kt) -------------------------------------------- LAKE OR RIVER NAME & NO. 11/23/10 Mavis Samuelson Leanne Magnotto came to the office today to discuss their plans for raising roof, adding dormers and an addition to existing dwelling. She had a scaled drawing of their plans and after reviewing them, a variance would be needed from the OHWL setback (Big MacDonald & Brown), the road right-of-way, and the proposed addition would be on top of the holding tank. We discussed moving and relocating an existing shed and placing the HT in that area. I suggested she have a septic system Designer/Installer onsite to see where the HT could be located. We ok'd best location for the HT previously (1993). The shed if relocated would require a variance from the OHWL. They proposed to change roof on existing shed to match the dormers on the dwelling. Also, may need to remove some impervious surface to keep within the 25%. She was going to calculate this before proceeding. I gave her a Variance Application and informed her that the BOA does not have meetings in the months of Jan., Feb. & March as they are unable to view projects due to snow cover and applicants are unable to stake projects as ground is frozen. She will consider these & disuss options and may wait until Spring to proceed. L&R OfRdal ♦♦♦ Date Action/Con I Date Action/Comments. Date L&R Official Action / Comments. L&R OfficialDate Action/Comments. L&R OfficialDate Action/Comments. L&R OfficialDate Action / Comments. L&R OfficialDate Action/Comments. ^^4 Ma/p.^7/0 ' 4/tY\p @ '?e-^/z ^1‘jjDl -i^^Ajnea y^A. Ij^iLpOuK jy4T ^PttJu,^ iT ^ OifFiCua 7» /y /%4. @ 2- <s>^nr- @ p. 1701 293 7302quest, marketingHu,g 28 09 12; 1 Ip Jim Lakoduk 171 N Woodcrest Drive Fargo, ND 58102 Ph. 701-298^578 Fax 701-293-7302 E-mail; questmg@aol.com Quest Marketing received land & RESOURCE T« Bill Kalar From: Jim LakoduK Faw 218-998-8112 Datee August 28.2009 Pages 2 R« Lot map West McDonald CC: □ Uigent □ For Review □ Please Comment □ Please Reply □ Please Recycle •Comments I talked to you a couple days ago regarding these lots and small cabin that my daughter and family is interested in. Attached is a map of the layout of the property. You'll note the two lots total 100’ on West McDonald and opens up to 123' on Brovm Lake. You’ll also note that the small home, only 20 x 28 is 25’ from the North lot line and 58’ from the South line and 33’ back from West McDonald. Hi Bill; The lot to the south of this property is narrow (front to back) and there are no structures. Some folks use it as access to the lake. The lot to the north is similar with a somewhat larger home on it and set back about the same. The question is do you feel there is any possibility getting a variance to allow making the home larger? I was linking another 22' to the South mailing the home 20’ x 50’ or 1000’ sq. ft. on the 7875 sq. ft. property. Any other suggestions on your part would be welcome. Thanks. 13 r ctnI aiJ’s /^ao<?q'ifo y^/ ooc? ji.oco*n^6 y^ioa^ ro03 ^ V if'a V . CD V - W>^ ***rofi\\0 1 ^^9ss c/av‘.‘<l^V4^p , h>^ n) ‘ 1 JQ C m -N ^\3 \D0 'i5«3 r 3U T t 4'!ID ft/I i <t? ^/K M-/J*^’1/O I’’«f1 ____I\*y rfk "Nt-_ SBl I i S; e \~?o'%# i 'O o roCDI *1 CO■Vi 'J CO o3>33«rozV^— 0 3 mo¥e°rc O33mC? c/0O '•y <ocz CZi m331o " fu> o-COm\ 90 ■3I1(iJjes^ ^LAK^ro ,*kO a I A ANDREW & LEANNE MAGNOHO 1202 8thStS FARGO, ND 58103 PARCEL NUMBER: 16000990461000 PROPERTY’ADDRESS:33453 CHARLIE TRAPP ROAD DENT. MN LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOTS 51 & 52, BLOCK 1, of CRYSTAL BEACH on WEST MCDONALD LAKE RequestingTo replace the roof on the existirig.20)^8 foot stmcture. The proposed replacement will be in the same footprint; The existing:pitch ofthe roof is 6:12 and will be replaced by a 12:12 pitch roof; Requesting to replace existing.16‘x10’ deck; which is currently 36 feet from the ordinary high water level (OHWL) and other impervious surfaces on property with a new 14x16 covered deck approximately 48 feet from the OHWL Replacement would.decrease the-impervious surfacefrom 13:7% to 12.8% (please see attached). The proposed replacement proj^t wiir be approximately48 feet back from the OHWL on West McDonald Lake and'35 feet back from OHWL on Brown Lake; Requesting.a 52’ setback variance from the OHWL on West McDonald and 165’ setback variance from OHWL on Brown Lake. The existing structure was built prior to October 15,1971. tot LI lVCai\on . • Cu.rrei\i 5*-^owi "IrVvs <Al)-ey, 2-^ -froirii . a ^'5' om Mt-Ponald La.\^€. -tv re^ac^e roof s^uc-+ure. ^\2acVL ^ar\0^u of ni/sfxom ’iB'^arta'OOL frov^ W)€&i W\cX:>rmM. Loca-^ov of loUX no+ be Chari^d ■ WHITE - Office GOLDENROD - Inspector .YELLOW - Owner (after issue) PINK - /Assessor • APPLICATION 1F(DR:SBTE'PERMIT LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL . GOVERNMENT SERVICES CENTER, 540 WEST FIR, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537 218-998-8095 www.co.otter-tail.mn.us PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL INFORMATION Permit No. LAKE; RIVER NO.5U>'3Su> 6G--/U/20 ^KE/RIVER NAME Srowvi________ LAKE/RIVER CLASS ,gp/N£ ' PROPERTY (E-911) ADDRESS SECTION TWP NO.RANGE TWP NAME 4-I\3i^o<oe/v PARCEL NUMBER (S) I u> (94Lp \ ODD 33^^03 04ftRj_>£"TEAPP LEGAL DESCRIPTIONLoVs , S>l0GVC I o-P C>'/5“I2l| ^xS3>-C|o MtXb»na.|c{ L-clL^ Last Name First Initial Mailing Address Daytime Phone No.KAAr44mTD AtA-pgEv^ ~r tvlA-r^KiCrTTO Le7VM<NlS- 6^ Property Qwrter '=4-g; FAtz/-^ MTT) Contractor Name Lie.# PROPOSED PROJECT (please circle the appropriate number) (2) Add'n to Dwelling (3) 'Replacement Dwelling { 5) RCU/Year; {6) Attached / Detached Garage (7) Add’n To Non-Dwelling {8) Storage Strocture (9)W.0.A.S. CO (tjQ^on-Conf. Replacement (,11) Other (identify)• ~ ' /£/ jC/ ^ ^ 'Existing Dwelling to be removed prior to ONSITE WATER SUPPLY (^^Ift^vidull ( ) Public ( ) None NOTE; MN Rules Chpt. 4725 (MN Well Code) requires a 3' (minimum) structure setback to a well. ONSITE SEWAGE TREATMENT SYSTEM(1 ) New Dwelling (4 ) MH/YR_____(j(L Pemil No. yy ( ) OTWMD have Sewage System Approval Irom OrWMD prior to issumg Site Permit. Contact Rollie Mann at 218-864-5533 erJ CHARACTERISTICS OF PROPOSED NON-DOutside Dimension Sq. Ft. Q 3 • ^Setback to Lotline ^ Ft. & y Ft." Setback to Right of Way Ft." Setback to Ordinary High Water Level Elevation Above Ordinary High Water Level ^ ^Setback to Septic Tank Setback to Drainfield Setback to Bluff Maximum Proposed Height____ Roof Change Yes ( ) No Bathroom Proposed { ) Yes cfiid^ACT^CTCS o{4)(opQ86 (Muj^j^D^^ache/Gar^e) ^ Outside Dimension '2S Ft. x CHARACTERISTICS OF PROPOSED W.O.A.S. (WATER ORIENTED ACCESSORY STRUCTURE ING m.6 Ftx 12-VOutside DimensionFt,"Ft." Ft. X Ft." So. Ft. Setback to Lotline /O^ F1.& jO^ Ft " Setback to Right of Way Z.p4- Ft." -.^Setback to Ordinary High Water Level Ft. Elevation Above Ordinary High Water LeveP ^ Ft. Ft. Sq. Ft.L Setback to Lotline____ Setback to Right of Way Setback to Ordinary High Water Leyef^____ Elevation Above Ordinary High Vrater Level Setback to Septic Tank Setback to Drainfield / Setback to Bluff / Maximum Prop^d Height Ft.&Ft." Ft. Ft. Ft. ^ Setback to Septic Tank Setback to Drainfield A" ^ Setback to Bluff Total Bedrooms Maximum Proposed Height Roof Change _(><fYes ( ) No Basement ( )Yes (^^No Walkout Basement ( ) Yes (side profile required) Ft. Ft. Ft. 7-P Ft Ft. Ft., Ft. ( ) Boatho)/^( ) Screen Porch ( ) Storage Structure( }Gi )0 **Project/Lotlines/Right"Of"ways Must be Staked Onsite Prior to Application / Inspection Topographical Alteration / Earthmovina ’’^sj^one □ 20 Cubic Yards or Less ‘ □ 21 Cubic Yards - 299 Cubic Yards' CHARACTERISTICS OF LOT: ’ Must include on scale drawing, additional Permit may be required.□ SOO Cubic Yards or More' 32a Inn Bluff { )Yes (yj xn I-T-Lp Lot Area.Sq, Ft.Water Frontage .Ft.No __QM__ Total Impervious Surface Onsite (FT^)Total Lot Area (FT^) Impervious Surface Ratio:X100 =.%Impervious Surface Ratio THIS IS A SITE PERMIT ONLY AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A BUILDING PERMIT AS SET FORTH IN CHAPTER 16, MINNESOTA STATE STATUTES. Agreement: I hereby certify that the information contained herein is correct and agree to do the proposed work in accordance with the description above set forth and according to the provisions of the Ordinances of OtterTail County, Minnesota. I further agree that any plans and specifications submitted herewith shall become a part of this permit application. I also understand that this permit is,valid for a period of six (6) months. Permit: Permission is hereby granted to the above named applicant to perform the work described in the above statement. This permit is;granted upon express con dition that the person to whom it is.granted, and his agent, employees and workmen shall conform in all respects to the Ordinances of OtterTail County, Minnesota. This permit may be revoked at any time upon violation of said Ordinances. I understand that it is my responsibility to inform the Land & Resource Management office once the building footings have been constructed. V-/V-//Date: Signature of Property Ovmer/Agent for Owner \Date; Land & Resource Management Office ^ PROJECT(S) TOTAL SQ. FT..PERMIT FEE $. RECEIPT NO. _ ■XT VAef ArJc€ / HAP/eu 2joHComments: Form No. BK — 1003-0407 329,562 • Victor Lundeen Co., Printers • Fergus Fslls, Minnesota April 14,2011 ' Page #5 ' Diane Kutzer—Approved the application as requestedvwith a condition. (8:23 p.m.) Diane Kutzer.LLC, Lot 6 Sandy Shore Development,'Otter Tail Lake in Everts Township, requested a variance to have Lot 6 Sandy Shore Development declared buildable for residential and nonresidential use. The plan is to construct a 32’ by 48’ by 10’ storage shed. The audience was polled with no one speaking for or.against the variance as requested. A letter from Ray DeBoever in support ofthe.variance as requested was read for the record. After consideration and discussion, Steve Schierer made a motion, second by Rick Wilson and unanimously carried, to declare Lot 6 Sandy Shore Development buildable for either residential or nonresidential use with the condition that no more than 25% of the total eligible lot area can be covered with impervious surfaces. It was noted that the variance as approved does not directly or indirectly grant any other, variances for any proposed or future development. Andrew & Leanne Magnotto - Approved the application as requested with a condition. (8:26 p.m.) Andrew and.Leanne Magnotto, Lots 51 and 52 Blqck1.of Crystal Beach, West McDonald Lake in Dora Township, requested the following: 'RequestJng:to^^!^^|ffrSgif?^|j!;^''g?e:k®TnfMfl^^.l7s^c^a|e. The.proposed replacement will be in the same footpri™ (he^isfin^iicrvOTinerdof is 6:12^d wffl^ replaced by a 12:12 pitch ^^^'frorntneor^l^v high *^water leveL Replacement would decreaselhe impervious'surface from 13"7% toi2^%. The proposed replacement project will be approximately-48’ back from the ordinary high water level on West McDonald Lake and 35’ back from ordinary high water level on '.Brown Lake. from the ordinary high water level onWest McDonald and 165’ setback variance fr(^ ordinary high wat^^^caBrown Lake. The current structure is approximately 8’ from the alley. .Proposed project vyill not change location. M Requesting-setback.variance of 177’ from .Brown Lake and.25’ variance from West McDon^d.^ ^^^^iSaiSSSI^IssWI Shed is 10’from holding tank. The audience was polled with no one speaking for or against the variance as requested. After consideration.and discussion:- gaBd-Sia:BaBim0,asLv£earliMiifg^iE§igS^^aalil'^'Sffie:q,i!jesre^B^sgfej0iSTedS0llI^lil^i^llilli^sw,g^lafe ^ ^lfwas^lse^^fl<^^SFi^^fe^i‘‘i^^^rov^^ra^tdirectly|or indirectly grant any other variances'thanlhose. outlined in the request. Hardship/practical difficulty is substandard lots of record and lakes on two sides of the property. ] EMmm le . ,.UJl\ I M Shirley A;Seaver -Approved the application as requested. (8:37 p.m.)Eugene R and iEugene R and Shirley A. Seaver, part of the Southeast Quarter of the Southeast Quarter, Section 17 of Henning Township, requested the following: Currently we have two parcels. One contains 3.67 acres and the other one contains.2.39 acres; We would like to take a portion ofthe 2.39.acre parcel (which measures 100’ by 400’ and attach it to the 3.67 acre.parcel, creating a parcel that would be-4.62-acres and creating a parcel that is substandard at 1.-46 acres. We wouljd like both lots to remain as buildable lots for residential use. The audience was not polled as there was no one in attendance at the tirhe of this public hearing. After consideration and discussion, Steve Schierer made a motion, second by Thomas Lee and unanimously carried, to approve the variance as requested in the application dated March 17,l201i and as depicted on the drawing submitted with the application. The variance as approved will provide the applicants with the ability to enjoy the same rights and privileges as others in this immediate area, both existing parcels contain dwellings and the smaller parcel of the two proposed parcels does meet the minimum size requirements forjplatted lots in' a non shoreland area. With no further business, Randall Mann, Chairman.declared the meeting adjourned at 8:42 p.m. Prepared by: . Wayn^tein, Secretary The minutes were-mailed on Friday, April 15, 2011 to the Otter Tail County-Board of Adjustment. Official action regarding these minutes will belaken by the Board-'of-Adjustment at their next regularly schedule meeting. I // . ^Li /f■% >]V jr/>Z /V7fI 1/••/• 1%<4Siir' ! iiLlP-li •t.ll r r |«S ■* H ’i ir~; ,>.i' " ^1 • < •> '»-V «... V ■-..- ^ .■ .V 51/2014^■ (. CURRENT IMPERVIOUS SURFACE: house - 560 sq.ft deck j- 264 sq.ft sidewalk - 54 sq.ft shed - 96 sq.ft TOTAL = 978 SQUARE FEET PROPOSED IMPERVIOUS SURFACE; ■560 sq.ft side stoop - 32 sq. ft porch - 224 sq. ft 96sqft house fronts screen shed- TOTAL = 912 SQUARE FEET IMPERVIOUS SURFACE REDUCED BY 66 SQUARE FEET TOTAL AREA OF PROPERTY = 7125 SQ. FT CURRENT AMOUNT OF IMPERVIOUS SURFACE = 13.7% PROPOSED AMONUT OF IMPERVIOUS SURFACE = 12.8% S/n/z^/f -'ANDREW & LEANNE MAGNOHO 1202 8|thStS FARGO, ND 58103 PARCEL NUMBER: 16000990461000 PROP ERTY ADDRESS:33453 CHARLIE TRAPP ROAD DENT. MN LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOTS 51 & 52. BLOCK 1, of CRYSTAL BEACH on WEST MCDONALD LAKE Requesting to replace the roof on the existing 20x28 foot structure. The proposed replacement will be in the same footprint. The existing pitch of the roof is 6:12 and will be replaced by a 12:12 pitch roof. Requesting to replace existing 16‘x10’ deck, which is currently 36 feet from the ordinary high water level (OHWli) and other impervious surfaces on property with a new 14x16 covered deck approximately 48 feet from th'e OHWL. Replacement would decrease the impervious surface from 13.7% to 12.8% (please see attached). The proposed replacement project will be approximately 48 feet back from the OHWL on West McDonald Lake and 35 feet back from OHWL on Brown Lake. Requesting a 52’ setback variance from the OHWL on West McDonald and 165’ setback variance from OHWL on Brown Lake. The existing structure was built prior to October 15,1971. 'Ths cuv^ren+ ^-hruMure -prc(yc\ lo<:ai]c>n . • CM.vrerv4 ‘SVif’d I5 3'-^owi -Hne <Al)-ey, 2-3 -froirv^ L(5vi^, 'Vo ^ oxY\ replrtie roof or. sVruc-htrf. varuna of ni7#ram -Bro.«n av.4 2B'vav\ar>U- fr.m W\cX>oaa)i. Loca-hoo of sV>e4 u^UJ, no+ be cY^a■n^A 5V\ea l5 lO'fWf Wo\aunj-t-nne.. » I I _ k‘=’______ ‘ iz-'t^ipe ^4 '^{|’i5Het= (l JfeASLg' C51W4 -i,4- Vx.\^3 4-rt®UQi4t.'V'NV^ 1I1 .' Vi !f^Korm LAitg ftonie i’d^^ops5'sci prziwI--*1;ST ^1 + 9Z- ,&Ui^t, CB^<'5^U 6B\0+Tlew l?EZ^ Ccc/VTIQN1 ll- 6XR-tW(7FerK- ■( It 1 ;I I 5>W5<. 10' WM4t_ I II !unFt.!e?!-urr 61 I I r m l*l&5-r \\:.\parn\vc7 ;ay 5; 2011 i'age # 2: Margaret Tucker -Approved’the variance;as: requested with conditions. {7:00 p.m.) MargaretvTucker ET AL, part of-Government Lot 1, Section 2"of Clitherall Township by West'Battle: Lake, requested:a variance to subdivide an existing:2;62 acre parcel into. two iotsL Each lot'would: have, 100’ of width. One of the. proposed'lots would havev59;300 square feet of area= and'the other lot would have.55,000 square feef of area. The minimum sizejfor metes and;bounds.parcels;in the shoreland area is 5:acres. The minimum size for platted: lots on a- general development lakevis. tOO’ ofwater frontage; TOO’ of width at'the building: setback and. 20,000. square-feet of • area. Also, requesting aivariance.to.leave an existing:shed less than 10’from the-proposed.lot line: Alice:Hofstad: represented:tne applicanfat:the public hearing; The audience was: polledrwith no one speaking fbr or against the variance-as re|quested. A letter from Bob and Becky Cox in opposition-to the variance as requested’was read.for the record: After consideration and.discussion, Steve Schierer made, a.motion, second by Thomas Lee and.carried with Rod Boyer voting no, to approve-the proposed 'subdivision as requested.with the conditions thaf a registered, surveyor’s drawing must be provided.and.all structures must'be placed at least 10’ from the lot line when the proposed subdivision is officially, recorded. Discussion of the.Magnotto Application - (7:10 p.m.); Thefbllowingiis-from the?April-14'; 2011'Bbard:ofAdjustment:Meeting:- Andrew-&Leanne:Magnotto - Approved;the application as,requestedrwith a'condition. (8:26 p.m:) Andrew and. Leanne:Magnotto; Lots. 5T and. 52’Block T of Crystal Beach, West McDonald Lake in Dora. Township, requested: the|following: Requestingitojreplaeethe roof on the existing. 20’ by 28’ structure. The-proposed repiacement will be in the-same fbotprint. The existing-pitch-of the roof is:6;T2 and:wiil be replaced, by a-T2:12.pitch roof Requestingjto replace existing 16’ by TO’ deck,.which is currently 36’ from the ordinary-high water level and other-impervious surfaces on property.with-amew T4’ by.16’ covered deck approximately 48’ from the ordinary high' wateflevel. Repracement.would:decrease the-impervious surface from 13.7% to 12.8%. The proposed replacement project will be|approximately.48’ back-from the:ordinary-high water-level on West McDonald: Lake and 35’ back from ordinary, high water level on Brown Lake: Requesting:a 52’ setback variance from the ordinary high waterlevei on West McDonald: and 165’ setback variance from ordinary-high water level on Brown Lake. The current structure is:. approximatelyj 8’from the-alley. Proposed projectwill.not change location: Current'Shed: is approximately 3.’.from the- alley, 23- from Brown Lake and: 75’ from West McDonald-Lake-- Pro'posingto.replace roof on existing: structure. Requesting setback variance of 177’ from Brown-Lake and-25’ variance frorh WestMcDonald. Location ofshed will. not be changed. Shed is; TO’-from holding: tank.The-audience was polled with no one speaking for or againstthe variance^as-requested-; After consideration'^'^d discussion, Randall Mann made armotion, second by Steve Schierer and unanimously carried, to approve-the vahance-as requested and.as-depicted.on the drawing submitted with the application with the condition-that:no portioq-.of the proposed: developmentcan be within 50’ of West McDonald Lake: It was.alsa noted that the:variances as:apprbved.do not directly or indirectly grant any other variances than those outlined in the request; Hardship/practieal difficulty is substandard:lots of record and lakes on two sides of the • property. , ^ ' } . Atthe May 5, 2011:Bbard:of AdjustmentrMeeting.— Mark Rbnning, Land and Resource-Department; reported.thafthe measurements presented at the April 14, 2011 ■ meeting were] not-accurateanda.'Site inspection indicated, additional concerns with the location of the holdingtank and the proposed development; After discussion and. consideration, Randall Mann made a motion, second by Steve Schierer and carried with RodrBoyer abstaining, to approve the variances'necessary to replace.the roof on the existing-20’ b} 28’ structure as-described, in the variance application and.to deny, all other variances:as requested for the -other development/improvements noted'in: the variance application. If should: be noted: that the \7ariance as approved:ailows improvements only to the existing dwelling and only in the exact:footprint.