HomeMy WebLinkAbout02000990749000_Variances_02-08-2000Variances
Barcode 128
\ *
OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER
OTTER TAIL MINNESOTA
I hereby certify that
this instrument #
was filed/recorded in this office
for record on the l~7 day of
_______________2000 at _Ull5_(^)fpm
Wendy L Metcalf, County Recorder
1 ^ ■ 1^0^ *fecording fee ^
well certificate
i 8621S6
bv;rBeputy
THE ABOVE SPACE IS RESERVED FOR THE COUNTY RECORDER
APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE
COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL
COURTHOUSE, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537
(218) 739-2271
“‘COMPLETE THIS APPLICATION IN BLACK INK /5i90iApplication Fee
Receipt Number
ADDRESS 7^^ ^ yk^ J ________
LAKE NUMBER.5Z?" LAKE
SECTION TOWNSHIP
PARCEL NUMBER O 2.0 ^T7^'72-S^ ^
72^PROPERTY OWNER DAYTIME PHONE
4
LAKE CLASS ,
/3V t/O 77 —
FIRE / LAKE I.D. NUMBER
RANGE TOWNSHIP NAME
LEGAL DESCRIPTION / y P) •<^<.=7r /-/- "2- / (y€2yiA^ A>-^
f *C «
r e
TYPE OF VARIANCE REQUESTED (Please Check)
Subdivision JTI. ClusterStructure Setback Structure Size___Sewage System Misc.
SPECIFY VARIANCE REQUESTED
/99(^* /9^y.n.
LAj~eA7L^
7c^J99 7
ryt-
'4 ^ /
ypT^ Ar-e. ^
'2^,
'Lm
I UNDERSTAND TMAT I HAVE APPLIED FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE SHORELAN
MANAGEMENT ORDINANCeSUBDIVISION CONTROLS ORDINANCE OF OTTER TAIL COUNTY.OA
I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED, IT IS MY RESPONSIBILITY TO
CONTACT LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT REGARDING THIS MATTER.
DATE
APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT THE HEARING(Applicant Will Receive Notification As To The DateATime Of Hearing)
April 6, 2000
Pa^ej,.?/
i)P
» *
S-/ ”
I
i?t ^/s/ooAccepted By Land & Resource
L & R Official/Date
JiC/CU
SCKTO
/7?a^h,
n-3oDate Of Hearing TimeI2.
Motion
Jon and Darlene Gunderson - Denied
Motion was made by Cecil Femling, second by Mark Steuart and unanimously carried, to deny the variance as
requested noting that no adequate hardship had been shown and the granting of the variance as requested would
not be consistent with past actions of the board.
irman/OtterTairCounty Boar^of Adjustment
Permit(s) required from Land & Resource Management
Yes (Contact Land & Resource Management)
No
Copy of Application Mailed to Applicant And the MN DNR
L R Official/Date
bk 0198-001
291.306 • Victor Lundeen Co.. Printers • Fergus Falls. Minnesota
March 30, 2000
Page i
Eulyn M. Feist - Approved with modification.
Eulyn M Feist, Fargo, ND, requested a variance of 43’ from the required ordinary high water level
setback of 75' and a variance of 5.5’ from the required shore impact zone setback of 37.5’ for the
placement of an addition 32’ from the ordinary high water level. The property is described as part of
Government Lot 3, Section 6 of Dunn Township by Pelican Lake. The audience was polled with no one
speaking for or against the request. After consideration, motion was made by Cecil Femling to approve
an addition to the rear of the existing structure with the condition that a 20’ separation from the drain
field must be maintained. This motion died for lack of a second. After additional consideration, motion
was made by Randall Mann, second by Steve Schierer and unanimously carried, to approve an
addition to an existing structure being no closer to the ordinary high water level then 37.5’ noting that
this will keep the addition out of the shore impact zone, will allow the applicant the opportunity to
connect two existing structures and will provide a reasonable use of the applicant’s property. Hardship
is the small size of the applicants’ property.
Kathleen R. Wright - Denied
Kathleen R. Wright, Valley City, ND, requested a variance “to allow fair use of a substandard lot.” The
variance needed is for the placement of an existing cabin with new construction less than 100’ from the
ordinary high water level and ahead of the existing building line. From the drawing it appears that the
existing cabin and new construction is approximately 63 to 67’ from the ordinary high water level. The
property is described as Lot 11 and the west half of Lot 12, Heaton’s Resort and Parcel H of
Government Lot 8, Section 2 of Sverdrup Township by East Lost Lake. James Wright, the applicant’s
son, appeared along with the applicant at the public hearing. The audience was polled with Diana
Beebout, a neighbor and Sverdrup Township Clerk, speaking to the request. She did not oppose the
applicant’s addition, but was concerned with how the Board of Adjustment would address previous
request that had been considered by this board and how the board would address future requests
should the applicant’s request receive approval at this hearing. After consideration, motion was made
by Mark Steuart, second by Steve Schierer and unanimously carried, to deny the variance as requested
noting the following;
1. no adequate hardship had been shown,
2. a portion of the addition is ahead of the string line,
3. the site permit application was not complied with as it indicates an ordinary high water level
setback of the string line,
4. a well was enclosed by the addition, which is a violation of the Minnesota Well Code, and
5. the applicant must bring the structure into compliance with the requirements of the shoreland
y management ordinance and with the provision of the site permit application by July 1,2000.
n and Darlene Gunderson - Tabled
Jon and Darlene Gunderson, Battle Lake, MN, request a variance which would allow residential
development on five back lots which are substandard by current ordinance requirements and which
were created after October of 1971 and before February of 1992. To restore these lots back to the
original residential use that was approved on August 10, 1976. The applicant has a home and garage
on Lot 22 that was build in 1997. The property is described as Lots 1 and 2, Block 1 and Lots 19, 20,
and 22, Block 2, Carr’s Subdivision, Walker and Otter Tail Lakes in Amor Township. An unsigned letter,
assumed to be from John Everts, was read for the record. The audience was polled with no one
speaking for or against the request. After consideration, motion was made by Randall Mann, second
by Cecil Femling and unanimously carried, to table this request until the April 6, 2000 meeting for a
report from Bill Kalar as to why these applicants were encouraged to reapply for a variance.
With no further business Chairman Mann declared the meeting adjourned at 10:35 p.m.
( X ) ) o jrf^
Wayne (^tein, Secretary
April 6, 2000
Page 6
on and Darlene Gunderson - Denied
Jon and Darlene Gunderson, Battle Lake, MN, requested a variance which would allow residential
development on five back lots which are substandard by current ordinance requirements and which
were created after October of 1971 and before February of 1992. To restore these lots back to the
original residential use that was approved on August 10, 1976. The property is described as Lots 1 and
2, Block 1 and Lots 19 and 20. Block 2, Carr’s Subdivision, Walker and Otter Tail Lakes in Amor
Township. A letter from John Everts in support of the application was read for the record. The
audience was polled with no one speaking for or against the request. Bill Kalar addressed the board
concerning this issued and advised the board of the Planning Commission position. The Planning
Commission position is not to recommend changing the ordinance to grandfather in those lots platted
after October of 1971 and before February of 1992, but rather to allow individual review of these lots by
the Board of Adjustment. The Planning Commission has noted that not all lots platted during this
period of time meet today’s building and development needs. After consideration, motion was made by
Cecil Femling, second by Mark Steuart and unanimously carried, to deny the variance as requested
noting that no adequate hardship had been shown and the granting of the variance as requested would
not be consistent with past actions of the board.
Other Business -
James Moline -
The application of James Moline was originally scheduled for a public hearing on Thursday, November
18, 1999. Prior to that meeting a request had been received to table the request until a later date.
Since that time the applicant has decided that the requested variance is no longer needed and has
requested permission to withdraw his request. After discussion and consideration, motion was made
by David Holmgren, second by Cecil Femling and unanimously carried, to acknowledge the applicant’s
request and to accept the applicant’s request to withdraw his application.
Kathleen Wright-
Kathleen Wright’s variance’s request was deny on Thursday, March 30, 2000. She has contacted the
Land and Resource Department questioning if the Board of Adjustment would allow the dwelling
addition to remain if they removed an existing structure down by the lake. It was brought to the
attention of the office and the board that perhaps other work had been done without proper permits.
After discussion, the Board of Adjustment indicated by general agreement that they where satisfied with
their decision of Thursday, March 30,2000 and were not interested in any tradeoff or compromise as
the applicant had not complied with their previous site permit and in fact my have done additional work
without first obtaining a permit.
S5G018 OFFICE OF COUNTY RECORDER
OTTER TAIL MINNESOTA
I hereby certify that
this instrument #
was filed/recorded in this office
for record on the dav of
1999 at ^:^/0(a^m
dy L. Metcalf, County Recorder
.Debuty^
/ ^ '^recordinq fee ^
'Tl (/U
Wen
by:
weil certificate
THE ABOVE SPACE IS RESERVED FOR THE COUNTY RECORDER
APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE
COUNTY OF OTTER TAIL
COURTHOUSE, FERGUS FALLS, MN 56537
(218) 739-2271
‘“COMPLETE THIS APPLICATION IN BLACK INK *4r*(pQ^ObApplication Fee
Receipt Number j/
/
PROPERTY OWNER ^ (KP CUl'CC/yUj PHOUE^7 ~ ^ ^
/ 4^/ fjTJjMJie. Thu 6^76^-
laJj
nc f
^703ADDRESS
l&laDLAKE NUMBER LAKE NAME LAKE CLASS
i2l /3<^<45SECTIONTOWNSHIPRANGE TOWNSHIP NAME
OAnM^ciff-V ‘ e'^^ooo
OP- ffioo p'r(^6/yi'X- pA
LEGAL DESCRIPTION / ^0^4.
‘-iO^jfirXXy
CLUjlUiklaU
PARCEL NUMBER FIRE / LAKE I.D. NUMBER
diMdCanbO
rf/ir
//
TYPE OF VARIANCE REQUESTED (Please Check)
structure Setback Structure Size Sewage System Cluster Misc.Subdivision
SPECIFY VARIANCE REQUESTED
I UNDERSTAND THAT I HAVE APPLIED FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE SHORELAND
MANAGEMENT ORDINANCeSUBDIVISION CONTROLS ORDINANCE OF OTTER TAIL COUNTY.
I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED, IT IS MY RESPONSIBILITY TO
CONTACT LAND & RESOURCE MANAGEMENT REGARDING THIS MATTER.■;f
//)//^/99
/" DATESIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER
APPLICANT MUST BE PRESENT AT THE HEARING(Applicant Will Receive Notification As To The Date/Time Of Hearing)
C..IClOi>L>'. I IS - SlS jS{/-
J J
Novembe
Page 8 dxyy
'7 So
7^y
'7^5 deep
^:\C’ ■ ^
7^,7
Aic^/^ y S^(p(o ysf
yS^Cicc^a^
753 dU 'J;
yS^/-oCci;J^
9.(p^89-000
~ 00/
'OO^
~ (P03
-oof
'OoS
‘'O0(/
' ^9-0/ o
79' o//
^9-0^3
39-y/^
96 -000
ooo
C(JLa^
13^
0.09
^QO'OOf
fo-9 ^'<-'<90 it16Sw75C.
l^doLp
>■- ~t t '
ySy
HD777
‘'OOf
-009 y^'S dup-
7^ -OOJ
- cjirO
L &ROfficial<Date / '
Accepted By Land & Resource
A/ojc>,ftjLe/?y99^/fi-7 O^-TimeDate Of Hearing
Motion
Jon and Darlene Gunderson - Denied
Motion was made by Cecil Femling, second by David Holmgren and unanimously carried, to deny the variance as
requested as no adequate hardship had been shown that would allow for the granting of the requested variance.
Chair^narTOttBr Tail County Board of^justment
Permit(s)^equired from Land & Resource Management
■ Yes (Contact Land & Resource Management)
/
No
7^ i iyi«Copy of Application Mailed to Applicant And the MN DNR
LR Official/Date
'7f
bk 0198-001
291,306 • Victor Lundecn Co.. Piinieis • Fergus Fells. Minnesota
. -^;. /. • .i'f.t .
::j
/^J S,ui I at •:
... .4
SUBDIVISIONCARR’Pftport4 Vf!\MMCRT a OSUM) a assoc, mc PART OF GOV'T LOTS 2.3.8.4,and PART OF SE.I/4 of NE. 1/4. SEC.12 AMOR TWPP«9rt f«l«, WMMWItt
^ - iMiratai Co. Caai inn 1
O'* MAic<
NmtnIiM NO TSTS inwNtf Mnna
■MMWical «caliMM 1 :'.rr«<TC r*rraa«ntoctor. cf
r:
riaHVCW $«■> iw eorr*-etl)‘
v.T ct.a pl4r;tlwc(NK.al iMwaiH T.s:r<K'.V TlacvO i:. t;.* n*
vutJiJa Lcur.ldty are corrna'ly .r ;.v.r-rT?^ ^Ua KifllaAjra on sr acrco* th*oienpc a« ehcwR.
Jtac* cf 1‘.u^.«s6 I-’,t*Tail
Seunqr etc JgOiL
tj T‘i Va
■k a.^..i.VL .21
, iiy : r_b«fcr>f SJt, cljs - • •result :. vjiur.-i.t;- ; tt fl*rM kfxwr.jcr. Mwrir^J in 4M who -it .rf44 h"lacutad asm -t fre* \ct uid dw3 ... (?>OCTAO.’tfcir.)
»• r.:f 9. Carr »rjd 5rueIfict •••! iV*«r,-
C- 'ini'.’iotifi’ P-Ue.-fri*cor-< of traiC'rr *:-» r-rep-iT
r,c>zeszi
*:.4 • «:.a ei,:/ii'J.-cticr *. .,er.uaut 4 .: z.'.* ttureno*/y-Vc-: t*• C'.^' cr Ccu.ty ^irs.i.:JieMtd sf Ccter “all 5f» _____
^ Ar.,io*T'i ai Cc>r.|f ’cti
«.,Ct?*r T*il Ci.Jt.ty Uy t:en2«jd J4 t Uw«t CuBff-*r.i;rv It '.rfrt.viiiit cctn-rtill Suvtsrmanc Lc.t c: Vtt-.-I;th«r.e4 :r. «r. snort
47* A*«t 01. tr,*, ’^rtMfly VI.l-JlSM
llr.w :f .iti 7c ,--r:f..4r.«:t i r « !t
ne if Ft»nr.*.ir.v .: zrtsz k-* 1--etil. UI'jSh,’''
ret
■J tu AttoiCM bjr:
4.0
.: I ■'s,\-- s:s*'i.i UC
rU:*
Vf i
WVC to CtlC z.'.*4.t .trr r.3cn, CeiiTcy
Cour.cy, inr.««o t a
L^rrittr.
tt.a :f 44:1 A.v-in>:.t 4 :ci ilit or. tfA MStil «6* jc* sr Ltiar Xatld»tt 1544.-.4 f-t.t;r:..*rrt., .• r. i
Ci«l
;r A.:..’ gigflay3l' 44* zmdiuo r-»-t :tf li t i:'Z-.f-jn ,r -.T -J^t 7fJ5» Seard.C.’ila^
..vt :-iat;;..wf> .lur
HOHCHT B OSLUNO S ASSOC INC
y \T
^ - Indicate Co. Coit inn rrom In plocc
0* md»corc« 0m iwu mtt> M«««iiNo TVS
i • - IndKOiM iroN found
B»onn^ on on ou4im«d dotiim
f soO.100
i.
i-I ' C-.. .
A''--7,>-IS3S
-lU'.tSr.-:
t 99 M't
r "■if'
tin NW Civ Vc 12 ^
Oi^ if *iiew#e*!'
.4irv«*y;chAt til JliCar^no *rn corr*-^t.y
'^iU£«rt:o t.:r --iiiarco c2 *.iv<
U.ui.ijry Ixi^h i*n crmtcriy i»*. 1
iic rxgtoayo cn tr sctzs t^« *■
r -r -r. tr*
tr. f:.«. ifi ^h»owr
.: I/-. ‘ t Qf* w
.•» «i; t» r —; ‘.i
WoHiof
; V / f .. If'...• rt, • ■--t^Co c?^ IT
Ccitrty .?i r ttfej Tiil )____________iay -; /
r.cifr: •, >,?. .->e k;twr**c3t7TT^
11 tcLdki 21
’ ,rclcr«r =^»*. tr -I ir. tr.l..C’ < f.ty t «»t0CTA4. No Sect*^ *. t ■* ‘-i ‘ • / - .. \l/ •; , • »i'iir'a 7x<^ .vrrvic*^,^rT-i..c:. >-.crii**J in 4ivi : •♦Ck.v jri -,'^z *«e na^cttlrU l*,^
y^r T^TT-i ivr. 1 r* "
•:,a:t» m* f5hif, rcMl-tif.j • '■fcio 4i i”ar ;rr^ ict «xui cUM,ET4i|
f "^v-*lor«* a, 'Zntt ir/i 7.
7*rr,u/r* rr *:*i r rctriotsxi* of t.*ut
.' tIt *1 J •►»>r^ft .r *. •• frr*’r.t Ur.. r,”;,Aui • tr-a cif.»tna Jcut.“-.*.-t i !.%;rtr.o«*t 4 o! J-rticr '. ,W ■• t ■.■ r.t •.m.OMM «M Towuinlp '71,'rAJj» 1 ,-ttst T»il jj.t>-.:'Sij,*...ta > --»CT*tii if t(tt« Till Ctwli ,:-iy..-Jot».thi3__
2TsAiruT,ao*T^ bt
V t • 7^ «czit*xi tj rdic;rf4:"-«rcci:v *S t':-* rUrtr.*j^Jt ccrt.>r 7"
Ixt 4;th«.c*? cf. A“ ‘r«fHf:r.j tl ?* **
ir* 4 *t M. tfi** *U./tr.rrly iir.u ;:'t < *-r:c“.-«rl Ut i i. i i
tin.' c! t3fi:r.t .r tr*.- tv »»• J- eiii-t;;..3iuth d •* : *• 47* dfc
1 Jl-r • 'A
). V.wt 'l.v.J cc tiw - :rr r **; i ‘Vv* '* t Att«-tftAi lTJ_. , , Ctrhff tfiot TirV Notcmol Bonii of Hevowu
Urfmeiom 0 Notionol Sank •• o Morf9Cd«i o# onO€ti**%‘ottcttbmO
4;thi?r.oo ’2.*'i4;;t cr. tr.f* lart^rly •i; .*• >- ,. •:«;i -irs> .1 I*.t 4 :.i i ;«r..5cn, Uaur.ty Auittcroc* J-* $:• ;*.-.t :v44.vtlrr Till Ccur.ty,Vlr.rojcuro-tcr and m lrst#ror^ t^mwof rti« %ot4 Nor<r>o( 9onfe fot couiod ?ur/r tc tn<» lott,c»f.tr^l triln o:Ajrrrv*^i ;y: ‘-t *• f •-* IJ.- wf '**'• •■'prncnf to bo in ir«if rrtpocli*^ Nofcnol Bon*,T T ?.i- 7i:vn 9o*rd,tnii____jjJ^cfAPiTtl.Ncrt;i ; ' .o'(. ^ . l {.i5C_-nr¥n« Dy triftf duty ouihonird oii<«« ond rt^ tobo hc<oi»"to Off.^d TfM Ctrdoy of AO JS 7/-
Natvjnol B^fSk^of Hcnmng
Artxr Et^i^farH] Pret
!• rt;t: «t <ro ,.v ; *. .•,. ry.
A! 4 trice iJ iv3cr;r.M ir t c^r iir quit cl*xc. ui.^i •
>">i- f'.:z r.witti 1 •* J' ‘ji* ». Ut ;:. F.it»tl)r ht.< .1 u.:t .j: ! ti.-t ' r .rr -.-r '. jrj :!i- ; It. V «. I ’ vl ii.t“-;r:Kpd Ly:! :;!.•. .•to i:.«f !.vrtr...*.vt coir.cf :;t»wx.cv !.ortn 4J* W-' t tr^i vi. t..*- tI/ .i:.-' ...r aiti trict t r *
u .t»;.C‘' rf lat l*-. t ni« *r lo.'s t3 t.r. .,'cr'*Utv'>UXk-t U»'*. !U tr-. il/ *:.i 7vit -• t«rl/ c:.
. .tt.'lir*- r: t*-- i: t*“i-• ct:u:t;. i .n.*- ■ rc_''ct.p
Z-'v: :htp ;v>n ;'P
I) i___• ffini CoiNtr .4ttost«d ly:*t I .»i i. ;r * •Ouone ::•. r; .• ; • -* ?•;'/r..;-r;t::-;.cc Jr.'Ulr*t *c r - :...'5. I : .i-'iM tr.l : j'L'^.ir.r fcvjvj It tc i>»t % • 4 . I 4 .■ ;' ; • .u •’•* ::•;. r ir C. 1; .; £.-£jffX0 and D*4*3oo .wno roth Oe*nq du'* ikd Uff
•*^of ore rev*«^«rr»f ”>e Pf»vd«nr :y«j fif^tNOtioraf borm of Herw^ni;.M«rr»nq Mmrs*
»*ul m< n;tn/T»€»'t •«» iiqnoo a-xl
w^:r* !.'•■-I V. , 4;.c j >•. - . .I rJir-i:x« vj Cttoi T^il
-----r^ir-
•••g. .t I- : 4 4-r- . . -f
• ;.
•UVtt Cl-.4*»j t;,*»«r:>-•IT-..- t' :•• ,.;rvoy*.<4 injv^o o No » *A- 1 r. i /• *.%,! t. I I:"fc
' • 4*i,i ioiiatt.. tv.%iO>«d in ticNjil
MM)
T^nwiry of its BoqtI of Ompc«mi ond said f^s.opr» an Cocnin* iV^MeOgd v®d insn^^nenl loto mej# free oct ord deed
t ■ f f 1.11 XV ! w t ^I.ii i.4 r’.l* i - 4iiCr i* -•: .
ficui r.:.;//Pi• .. --jt .*«kiv in if^rcv’oil t.*Us^-■ •If,
i».
- if f L.
„..COi««ty »U«naoi9n*iMc i::
\Wy Cttnmr^von
v.r.c*- .Ill
• t *T '• .: . I . • ■ '-.;-io;.rc .. f titlo ra.i l»:«rr4 ^
<V-T.rT).hrrM.y
tj -o tr.v ncp.rty in tr.i«
Ttite ct .Vir.n^sct-i )' M&Oft!»p4A vx* cv*t;cr..;j-'■"■ty <>f oT>xvf75/C
„Jjy . !'_/>P4,|t.
L*-xng C.^« ^In rwx.i-fj cf i
Cn tMa ^ jI l4.'„ ^ ^ srFt'Sf'-l r>w«i>!cf.' Carr i:*.i Hr-c* T. 7ir<
cl -Iff if ire<p *J*r»icn ir. I if- to le known to be tJ’.c pvf .on;4tte...t tc t-.o CAcZ tt%*t »re:4j^.nci in tr.e :rr'*joi:j ir,:*cn*£4>r.t»e.
M i*- ’ ‘ 4S4nd trat t.nt</ t.Vi ^hdir^gr. fr«-« oc^ jri-i
. i»vtlf7 KxLljc
SUbJifjstot
'>Tm is to Certit"f tVrt C»co*ston NaT»ona» Ban* «4 C^kifonl^nwe*()*q
fftt-mony .nefeof tt»« M'd Nd*cnol Book hqi cckited th**.
t»ome »v rnc.r dui* OMfforut^ off<ef» ord iHeir »*ol lo b« her* 2!
C*ock»rw Not.onoi Bonk
I 0n^eor* and »n
z i BonkmaOmni IAN .Tvui ty,rirciv.«3t«»QTraPtmmlL,.* *4